Monday, November 15, 2004

Breaking the Doctor-Patient Relationship: The Suing Patient

I would like to bring up an issue for discussion that has to do with a breakdown in the doctor-patient relationship. What should happen to the relationship if the patient initiates a malpractice suit against the doctor or the medical clinic and yet apparently has not terminated the professional relationship? This event has happened in the past. What could be the consequences if the relationship was to continue? Would each party have sufficient trust in the other to make the doctor-patient interaction therapeutically effective?



In a San Diego, CA case Scripps Clinic v. Superior Court (Thompson) (2003), Cal.App.4th [No.D040569. Fourth Dist., Div. One. April. 17, 2003], a physician-group practice rationalized the decision to transfer the patient to another clinic by arguing that a physician having received an intent to sue letter "irreparably compromises the physician-patient relationship, thereby potentially compromising the care rendered to the patient. Patient litigants might not be as forthcoming for fear that evidence or information would be used in their lawsuit. Further, patients may also believe that their physicians will not give them balancedcare...for example, they might believe that a physician who does not timely return a telephone call is punishing the patient." (Thanks to Lance K Stell, PhD, FACFE, Charles A. Dana Professor of Philosophy, Director, Medical Humanities Program, Davidson College, PO Box 7135,Davidson, NC 28036 for the reference.) Does the physician or clinic at this point have the right to decide not to continue treating the patient and transfer the patient to another physician or clinic, if the patient’s medical condition allows the patient to be safely transferred? What if the patient lives in a geographic area where transportation to another caregiver would be lengthy and inconvenient?



It is my understanding that as the patient has the legal right to sue and the physician or clinic has the legal right not to accept a patient except in an emergency and a right to terminate care, not to abandon the patient but transfer the patient safely to another equivalent healthcare provider. But in this particular situation what is your opinion? ..Maurice.

Sunday, November 14, 2004

Possible Conflict of Interest:Doctors Selling Products and Owning Stock

As a segue from complementary and alternative medicine, consider the physician selling to the patient, out of the office, potions and lotions of alternative medicine which may have equivocal efficacy. Consider, the physician selling pharmaceuticals which have proven benefit or other products which may also be found in drug stores. What do these action do to the doctor-patient relationship? If a doctor prescribes but also sells to the patient a medication, can the patient be sure that the doctor's prescription was not based on the doctor's self-interest rather than the interest of the patient? Would a cheaper medication that the doctor was not dispensing be equally as effective? Some have equated this action as equivalent to a physician referring the patient to a lab or X-ray facility of which the physician had financial interest. Are these behaviors on the part of the physician ethical?

One can also extend the ethical concerns to physicians who own stock in certain pharmaceutical companies or have been treated to some benefit by a pharmaceutical company. Should patients consider that the physician might be prescribing a particular brand of medicine because of this influence? Should each patient be made aware at the outset of all potential conflicts of interest that their physician bears? Or should the patient always assume that a physician's interest is always in the patient? Please write me your comments on this issue.



As a resource to learn more about the issue of the physician selling products from his or her office, read the position paper representing the Ethics and Human Rights Committee of the American College of Physicians titled "Selling Products Out of the Office" by

Gail J. Povar, MD and Lois Snyder, JD, for the Ethics and Human Rights Committee, Annals of Internal Medicine, 7 December 1999 | Volume 131 Issue 11 | Pages 863-864. Here is an abstract of that paper. ..Maurice.





The sale of products from the physician’s office raises several ethical issues and may affect the trust necessary to sustain the patient-physician relationship. When deciding whether to sell products out of the office and, if so, which ones, physicians should carefully consider such criteria as the urgency of the patient’s need, the clinical relevance to the patient’s condition, the adequacy of evidence to support use of the product, and geographic and time constraints for the patient in otherwise obtaining the product. Physicians should make full disclosure about their financial interests in selling the product and inform patients about alternatives for purchasing the product. Charges for products sold through the office should be limited to the reasonable costs

incurred in making them available.










Friday, November 12, 2004

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (6)

I am going to leave the issue of the ethics of CAM now.. but I do want to refer those who want to continue this thread to another blog, Complementary and Alternative Medicine Law Blog. This blog is devoted to CAM and presents news items and discussions of the legal implications as well as the ethical and many other aspects of CAM practice. You should find the site rewarding as another resource. ..Maurice.

Wednesday, November 10, 2004

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (5)

In order to best understand the benefits found in the use of the various modalities of alternative medicine, evidence-based conclusions need to be presented. These conclusions are based on careful review of as many research projects available in the literature done to look for benefits of a particular modality for a particular disease or disorder. The reviewer must be able to establish that the research trial was devised to meet scientific criteria and attempt to find statistically significant data. These projects are then compared and together, a conclusion about benefits as well as harms can be established. This review then becomes the basis for rational use of the alternative medicine modality in the specific disease.



There is a developing web-site that has begun such a review of CAM studies. It is called "Complementary and Alternate Medicine" and is an evidence-based resource from New Zealand about complementary and alternative medicine. Recently completed reviews include Arnica creams, gels and sprays for the treatment of soft tissue injury; Cranberry for the prevention of urinary tract infection; Acupuncture for smoking cessation; Horse chestnut seed extract for the treatment of chronic venous insufficiency; and Garlic for the treatment of calf pain when walking. The results are summarized and a conclusion is given. A description of the modality and a description of the medical condition is also given for visitor education.

The URL for this important resource is http://www.cam.org.nz

..Maurice.

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (4)

My view of complementary and alternative medicine is that the practice should be more complementary than alternative. What I mean is that I think that the very best treatment for the patient, if alternative treatment is considered, should be a carefully orchestrated combination of both alternative and conventional standard medicine with practitioners of both disciplines working together. There is no doubt that alternative medicine has something to offer patients. For one example is the attention that the alternative practitioner provides to the patient. There is something important provided to the patient with the “listening to the patient” by the chiropractor and others in alternative medicine or the “laying on of hands” by the chiropractor or those practicing “therapeutic touch.” Medical doctors are often criticized for such deficiencies in terms of their brief history taking and their perfunctory physical examinations.



With regard to the therapeutic benefits of the techniques or substances administered, there is certainly the possibility that they provide a benefit through the so-called “placebo” effect. This effect would not involve a direct physical or pharmacologic action but produce benefit indirectly through unknown or psychologic or behavioral mechanisms. Direct benefits must be proven by research studies.



What are the ethical implications of alternative medicine as integrated into conventional medicine? I agree with much of the concerns and conclusions written in the articles of the previous two postings. With regard to establishing a benefit beyond a placebo effect, many of the techniques or substances could be subjected to controlled studies with care taken to provide the same informed consent and protection to the subjects as research studies done in conventional medicine. When alternative medicine is used with conventional medical treatment, the orchestration mentioned above should include care that the patient is not harmed or burdened by either method, that the interference of the methods be minimized and that the patient should be informed about the all the risks and known benefits. There will be cases where conventional medicine has reached a dead end in terms of specific therapy for the illness. This is where conventional medicine must reach out with comfort care to the patient and not simply abandon the patient to alternative medicine. The medical doctor should not extinguish the little flame of “hope” which the patient holds but still be realistic in talking to the patient and support the patient if the patient wishes to try alternative medicine as long as this is part of a program of comfort care for which the medical doctor is managing.



As you see,in this posting,I am supporting the view of the patient always engaging in complementary medicine rather than going out and obtaining alternative medicine on their own. My rationale is that diseases are based on anatomical,physiologic,psychologic,biologic,pharmacologic,biochemical and physical principles and the practitioners who have the best education for treating diseases are the medical doctors (or modern osteopaths)and therefore they should never remain outside the care of the patient.You may hold a different view and I certainly would like to hear from you. Please write your comments on this subject. ..Maurice.





Monday, November 8, 2004

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (3)

JAMA -- Abstract: Ethical Issues Concerning Research in Complementary and Alternative Medicine, Franklin G. Miller, PhD; Ezekiel J. Emanuel, MD; Donald L. Rosenstein, MD; Stephen E. Straus, MD



JAMA. 2004;291:599-604.



The use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) has grown dramatically in recent years, as has research on the safety and efficacy of CAM treatments. Minimal attention, however, has been devoted to the ethical issues relating to research on CAM. We argue that public health and safety demand rigorous research evaluating CAM therapies, research on CAM should adhere to the same ethical requirements for all clinical research, and randomized, placebo-controlled clinical trials should be used for assessing the efficacy of CAM treatments whenever feasible and ethically justifiable. In addition, we explore the legitimacy of providing CAM and conventional therapies that have been demonstrated to be effective only by virtue of the placebo effect.

Thursday, November 4, 2004

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (2)

An issue which can be raised regarding complementary and alternative medicine is whether the physician’s advice to patients encouraging use of the modalities involved and their use is indeed ethical. Adams, Cohen, Eisenberg and Jonsen writing in the Annals of Internal Medicine present some criteria which if considered may pave the way to ethical use in appropriate patients. The following is the abstract from the Annals article. ..Maurice.





From the Annals of Internal Medicine, 15 October 2002 | Volume 137 Issue 8 | Pages 660-664



Ethical Considerations of Complementary and Alternative Medical Therapies in Conventional Medical Settings



Karen E. Adams, MD; Michael H. Cohen, JD, MBA, MFA; David Eisenberg, MD; and Albert R. Jonsen, PhD





Increasing use of complementary and alternative medical (CAM) therapies by patients, health care providers, and institutions has made it imperative that physicians consider their ethical obligations when recommending, tolerating, or proscribing these therapies. The authors present a risk–benefit framework that can be applied to determine the appropriateness of using CAM therapies in various clinical scenarios. The major relevant issues are the severity and acuteness of illness; the curability of the illness by conventional forms of treatment; the degree of invasiveness, associated toxicities, and side effects of the conventional treatment; the availability and quality of evidence of utility and safety of the desired CAM treatment; the level of understanding of risks and benefits of the CAM treatment combined with the patient’s knowing and voluntary acceptance of those risks; and the patient’s persistence of intention to use CAM therapies. Even in the absence of scientific evidence for CAM therapies, by considering these relevant issues, providers can formulate a plan that is clinically sound, ethically appropriate, and targeted to the unique circumstances of individual patients. Physicians are encouraged to remain engaged in problem-solving with their patients and to attempt to elucidate and clarify the patient’s core values and beliefs when counseling about CAM therapies.