One of the ethical issues that face the transplant program in the United States involve “who”gets to donate an organ and “who” gets to receive the organ. Of current ethical concern pertaining to “who” gets to donate is the condemned prisoner on death row. The other ethical concern pertaining to “who” gets to receive the organ is the convicted criminal. There are other ethical “who”s which I will note later.
There is always discussion with regard to increasing the pool of potential organ donors. There has been a suggestion made for a proposal or law which would allow a prisoner condemned to die to have the sentence changed from death to life imprisonment by, for example, a kidney donation. The concerns are summarized in white papers written by the ethics committee of UNOS (United Network for Organ Sharing), the U.S. government designated organ procurement network. The committee wonders whether the “proposals would be coercive to particular classes of individuals--minorities and the poor” which may well represent the classes most likely found on death-row. Further, “would the reduction in sentence apply to the offer to donate, or would it only be honored if the act of donation took place? If the act of donation would exclusively qualify for the reduction in sentence, then the law or policy would discriminate against individuals found to be medically unsuitable to donate organ.” Additionally, concern is expressed about the reaction of jurors deciding punishment if they were aware of the possibility of trading an organ for reduction of sentence from death to life in prison. “…potential jurors could be influenced and ultimately impose the death penalty more often with a potential societal benefit in mind. Jurors might hope that the convicted persons would choose to trade their kidney for their life. This would present a gross inequity for those unable or unwilling to donate a kidney and who might otherwise have not received a death sentence.” Another issue would be if physicians were involved in the execution process itself in order to procure healthy organs for transplant. This would represent unprofessional and unethical behavior on the part of those physicians. Can you think of some more ethical problems with prisoners as organ donors?
With regard to convicted prisoners receiving organs, the UNOS ethics committee paper reminds us of the view that “convicted criminal status should be irrelevant in the evaluation for candidacy as a potential transplant recipient. This position assumes that convicted criminals have been sentenced only to a specific punishment, i.e., incarceration, fines, or probation. However, the convicted criminal has not been sentenced by society to an additional punishment of an inability to receive consideration for medical services. This argument also emphasizes that criminals not sentenced to death are expected to return to society and be deemed worthy of equal treatment in the receipt of other items/services distributed by society.” However, the medical and psycho-social criteria that are used to evaluate any potential recipient for organ transplant would equally apply to the prisoner.
Finally, I might add a couple more “who”s to the list of ethical issues that have been written about regarding organ transplant. Should a parent give permission for their minor child, who may be at an age without the capacity to make their own decision, to donate a kidney for a needy sibling? And with regard to “who” gets the organ, if the recipient is specifically designated by the donor to receive the organ, should this trump other worthy patients on a transplant recipient list? Should a patient use the Internet to try to directly contact potential donors and bypass the UNOS system to obtain the needed organ? And if you were a Supreme Court justice and because you were a Supreme Court justice, would you expect to get a kidney, bypassing others on the list? To the last question, the answer from UNOS is a resounding “NO”. Although the example of a justice is not mentioned, all patients on the list are to be justly evaluated. ..Maurice.
Tuesday, February 22, 2005
Monday, February 21, 2005
Organ Donation: Who, How,Why and also What are the Ethics? (1)
The need by the sick for donated vital organs far exceeds the supply. Through the years the supply was provided primarily by certain organs obtained from freshly deceased patients and from live donors who altruistically donated a kidney, part of a lung or part of a liver as example. For the most reliable organs to be obtained after transplantation into a sick patient, the organ needs to have maintained good circulation and oxygenation and therefore should be removed as soon as possible after death or better while the donor is alive as in the case of the live volunteer.
In order to increase the numbers of organs available, the concept of brain death was developed. This condition is identified if there is neurologic evidence of complete and irreversible absence of function of the whole brain including the brain stem where respiration and cardiovascular control is located amongst other functions. A brain dead patient is therefore considered dead and even though the heart may still be beating for a while and while respiration is being maintained by machine, organ procurement can be ethically and legally begun with the previous permission of the patient and/or the family.
Finally, another source for organs has gained popularity given, as stressed by ethical consensus in recent years, that care is taken to conform to strict ethical boundaries. This source is termed non-heart beating organ donation. The valuable aspect of this source is that the donor patient can be kept alive until the surgeons are ready to procure the organs and therefore the organs will be in better condition than from a patient whose death was spontaneous and maybe unwitnessed. The non-heart beating organ source is a patient who is terminally ill and by advance directive has declared that he or she did not want to be maintained on life-support if there was no hope for recovery and the either the patient or family agreed to an organ donation. In this case, even without organ donation, the patient’s life-support such as ventilator and blood pressure maintaining medications would be at some point removed and the patient would then die. In the case of organ donation, the point in time when the life-support is removed is determined when the surgeons are ready to procure the organs. While the surgeons are standing by, the life-support is terminated and then the patient is observed for the heart to stop beating. When this occurs, there is a wait of from 2 to 5 or even 10 minutes and if the heart does not resume, the patient is considered dead and the operation to obtain the organs begins. If the patient’s heart continues to beat, the patient is usually watched for another hour and if no cardiac arrest has occurred by then, any attempt of procurement is abandoned and the patient is returned to the ward for comfort care until death occurs.
I will discuss in my next posting some of the ethical issues involved with organ donation including brain death and the non-heart beating donation. Can you think of some of them yourself? ..Maurice.
In order to increase the numbers of organs available, the concept of brain death was developed. This condition is identified if there is neurologic evidence of complete and irreversible absence of function of the whole brain including the brain stem where respiration and cardiovascular control is located amongst other functions. A brain dead patient is therefore considered dead and even though the heart may still be beating for a while and while respiration is being maintained by machine, organ procurement can be ethically and legally begun with the previous permission of the patient and/or the family.
Finally, another source for organs has gained popularity given, as stressed by ethical consensus in recent years, that care is taken to conform to strict ethical boundaries. This source is termed non-heart beating organ donation. The valuable aspect of this source is that the donor patient can be kept alive until the surgeons are ready to procure the organs and therefore the organs will be in better condition than from a patient whose death was spontaneous and maybe unwitnessed. The non-heart beating organ source is a patient who is terminally ill and by advance directive has declared that he or she did not want to be maintained on life-support if there was no hope for recovery and the either the patient or family agreed to an organ donation. In this case, even without organ donation, the patient’s life-support such as ventilator and blood pressure maintaining medications would be at some point removed and the patient would then die. In the case of organ donation, the point in time when the life-support is removed is determined when the surgeons are ready to procure the organs. While the surgeons are standing by, the life-support is terminated and then the patient is observed for the heart to stop beating. When this occurs, there is a wait of from 2 to 5 or even 10 minutes and if the heart does not resume, the patient is considered dead and the operation to obtain the organs begins. If the patient’s heart continues to beat, the patient is usually watched for another hour and if no cardiac arrest has occurred by then, any attempt of procurement is abandoned and the patient is returned to the ward for comfort care until death occurs.
I will discuss in my next posting some of the ethical issues involved with organ donation including brain death and the non-heart beating donation. Can you think of some of them yourself? ..Maurice.
Sunday, February 20, 2005
Dying Slowly and Finding "What a most delicious piece of fruit"
A monk was being chased by a panther when he found himself on the edge of an embankment. His eyes rapidly scanned the bank. He saw a rope which he believed would serve as his escape route. He quickly began his descent, but looking down he saw a second panther waiting below. He looked up again, this time to see a mouse gnawing on the rope. He stopped. In front of him and within arm's reach he saw a ripe strawberry. He picked and carefully placed it in his mouth. 'What a most delicious piece of fruit,' he said.
Wayne Holst starts his book review of "What Dying People Want: Practical Wisdom for the End of Life", by David Kuhl in Western Catholic Reporter October 2002 with that Zen Buddhist lesson. Continuing, Holst writes:
'The moment someone is told that their illness will likely result in death, time changes,' writes David Kuhl. It is an occasion unlike any other.
Kuhl, a Soros Faculty Scholar for the Project on Death, specializes in helping people better understand the experience of dying and bereavement. He is committed to influencing change in the way our culture treats death.
The author, a Vancouver-based physician, believes that - dreaded as it is - the realization of impending demise can actually transform the experience of dying into a special time.
Read the entire review. You may also wish to read the book itself. I think to better support the patient, each physician caring for a slowly dying patient needs to have some understanding of how the patient is emotionally and spiritually handling the remaining lifetime. This may be difficult because of the physician's schedule but probably there is more to this difficulty than time. There may be a tendency for a physician to begin to draw away from the dying patient because of associated personal feelings of inadequacy or failure. And this would be terribly unfortunate for the patient because of the patient's need at this time for comfort support both physical and emotional. This period in the patient's illness can represent one of the most challenging times for the patient but also challenging for the patient's doctor. The physician's response to the patient's needs at this time will separate those who are simply Dr.Technician from those who are Dr.Marcus Welby,M.D. ..Maurice.
p.s.- To complement this subject you may also want to read the posting about "Telling Bad News". Scroll down to July 18, 2004 for that piece.
Saturday, February 19, 2005
Patient: "There is no preparation for a death sentence, is there?"
Doctor: “There is a lifetime.”
For those who die swiftly there is usually the absence of pain and suffering and that is good. For those who die slowly, there is often the burden of pain and suffering which medical science cannot always fully remove. And this is the dark side of dying slowly. But there is a bright side which those who die swiftly never have the chance to experience. The bright side is having some time to review the years of your life which have gone by and perhaps finding meaning to living that you never really experienced previously. Dr. William G. Bartholome, M.D., a pediatrician and ethicist had a chance to die slowly with his esophageal cancer and he wrote about the bright side. (“Living in the Light of Death,” Bulletin 45(2): 52, University of Kansas Medical Center, April 1995)
Dr. Bartholome died August 2nd 1999. ..Maurice.
p.s. (Added 2-26-05) For those who would like to learn more about dying from the aspect of the dying patient, the family, physicians and hospice care, click
here to go to NPR and "All Things Considered" for transcripts and audio (you need RealPlayer). This location contains the beginning segment of a week-long presentation of death and dying produced in 1997.
For those who die swiftly there is usually the absence of pain and suffering and that is good. For those who die slowly, there is often the burden of pain and suffering which medical science cannot always fully remove. And this is the dark side of dying slowly. But there is a bright side which those who die swiftly never have the chance to experience. The bright side is having some time to review the years of your life which have gone by and perhaps finding meaning to living that you never really experienced previously. Dr. William G. Bartholome, M.D., a pediatrician and ethicist had a chance to die slowly with his esophageal cancer and he wrote about the bright side. (“Living in the Light of Death,” Bulletin 45(2): 52, University of Kansas Medical Center, April 1995)
To live in the bright light of death is to live a life in which colors and sounds and smells are all more intense, in which smiles and laughs are irresistibly infectious, in which touches and hugs are warm and tender almost beyond belief. To live in this awareness of who, what, and where I am is to live more fully than I ever dreamed possible. Life doesn’t seem like a box of chocolates; it seems like endless servings of incredibly rich chocolate mousse.
I had not known this kind of living before. I wish that the “final” chapter in all your stories will be one in which you are given the gift of some time to live with whatever illness proves to be your fatal illness. But even more, I wish that you could discover what I now know — that this is the only way for us humans to live!
Dr. Bartholome died August 2nd 1999. ..Maurice.
p.s. (Added 2-26-05) For those who would like to learn more about dying from the aspect of the dying patient, the family, physicians and hospice care, click
here to go to NPR and "All Things Considered" for transcripts and audio (you need RealPlayer). This location contains the beginning segment of a week-long presentation of death and dying produced in 1997.
Friday, February 18, 2005
The Ethics Committee Consortium: Working Together to Make Better Ethics
Believe it or not, even though clinical ethics has been around as a formal discipline for well over 20 years and many ethical issues are more or less settled both ethically and legally, there are still areas of ethical consternation. Most hospital ethics is the pervue of a committee (usually called the hospital ethics committee) now specifically required for hospital federal certification. I have described the history, composition and function of the hospital ethics committee in my posting of December 17,2004. Each committee in each hospital in the U.S. creates its own policies or guidelines, in their own terms, to deal with numerous situations which may arise from "do not resusitate" to organ donation to withdrawal of life support. If any of these issues ever went to court because of a conflict which could not be resolved within the hospital, each policy and guideline would be specifically scrutinized by the court and then perhaps compared with those from other hospitals. This potential for court scrutiny and the possiblity that some legal error might be found to the detriment of the hospital's case has become of more concern when yet controversial issues persist such as the definition of futility.
To mitigate against this possibility is one of the motivating forces that has led to the development of ethics consortiums in which a number of hospital ethics committees within a geographic area have come together to meet and present to each other their issues and the actions taken. Besides disseminating experiences, these consortiums are able to work together to try to form a consensus regarding policies and guidelines for these still controversial issues. If this is sucessfully completed and utilized by all the hospitals participating, such consensus documents would be expected to represent a standard of acceptable ethical decision-making if a conflict is taken to court.
As an example of such an active consortium, I am participating as representative of my local hospital in the Southern California Bioethics Committee Consortium where over 50 hospitals in the Southern California area are members. Each representative reflects their committee members who comprise mixed professional disciplines and include community (not hospital affiliated) members. The current issue is who should be the surrogate decision maker for incompetent patients who have no family, friends or anyone else who knows the patient and could be a surrogate. Hopefully, if we all can come to a consensus our final guidelines on this topic will bear more legal clout and ethical comfort than a document written by each hospital alone. ..Maurice.
To mitigate against this possibility is one of the motivating forces that has led to the development of ethics consortiums in which a number of hospital ethics committees within a geographic area have come together to meet and present to each other their issues and the actions taken. Besides disseminating experiences, these consortiums are able to work together to try to form a consensus regarding policies and guidelines for these still controversial issues. If this is sucessfully completed and utilized by all the hospitals participating, such consensus documents would be expected to represent a standard of acceptable ethical decision-making if a conflict is taken to court.
As an example of such an active consortium, I am participating as representative of my local hospital in the Southern California Bioethics Committee Consortium where over 50 hospitals in the Southern California area are members. Each representative reflects their committee members who comprise mixed professional disciplines and include community (not hospital affiliated) members. The current issue is who should be the surrogate decision maker for incompetent patients who have no family, friends or anyone else who knows the patient and could be a surrogate. Hopefully, if we all can come to a consensus our final guidelines on this topic will bear more legal clout and ethical comfort than a document written by each hospital alone. ..Maurice.
Thursday, February 17, 2005
“Bedside Rationing”: Is It Ethical? Would It be Effective?
There has been much discussion in recent years about “bedside rationing”. These discussions really involve the issue of what is the ethical role of the physician. Is it to provide the best treatment to the patient with only the patient's beneficence in mind or is it also to consider the societal implications of medical care and to withhold certain treatments to specific patients because of costs or scarcity, thus perhaps providing beneficence to society in general? After all, one may argue, that it is society who has given physicians their special privileges and therefore physicians should also be responsible to society.
In an excellent journal review of the issue of bedside rationing, Renee Witlen writing in Virtual Mentor first considers the views of P.Ubel, R,Arnold "The unbearable rightness of bedside rationing: physician duties in a climate of cost containment".( Arch Intern Med. 1995;155:1837-1842). She then presents opposing views. Here is an excerpt from the beginning of the Virtual Mentor article. I would strongly advise my visitors to click on the link above to read the entire piece.
Do you think that bedside rationing is fair and would be effective only in countries that have national health plans, where there is a more uniform allocation of healthcare resources as compared to our USA private/governmental forms of healthcare delivery? Let me know what you think. ..Maurice.
In an excellent journal review of the issue of bedside rationing, Renee Witlen writing in Virtual Mentor first considers the views of P.Ubel, R,Arnold "The unbearable rightness of bedside rationing: physician duties in a climate of cost containment".( Arch Intern Med. 1995;155:1837-1842). She then presents opposing views. Here is an excerpt from the beginning of the Virtual Mentor article. I would strongly advise my visitors to click on the link above to read the entire piece.
In their 1995 article, 'The Unbearable Rightness of Bedside Rationing: Physician Duties in a Climate of Cost Containment,' Drs Peter Ubel and Robert Arnold assert that physicians should engage in bedside rationing in order to contain rising health care costs. They define bedside rationing as 'physicians"actions to withhold beneficial care from patients that physicians were free to offer them" and confine their discussion to rationing done "either without patients being aware of the rationing or, less often, with patients being aware but being given no choice". Many physicians and ethicists have rejected this role for physicians in the belief that physicians must advocate for the individual patient, even acting, if necessary, against the "apparent interests of society as a whole". Ubel and Arnold contend that if bedside rationing is conducted correctly, it is morally acceptable and, in conjunction with rationing decisions at higher levels of health care organizations, constitutes the only viable way to contain health care costs in the short and medium term.
Do you think that bedside rationing is fair and would be effective only in countries that have national health plans, where there is a more uniform allocation of healthcare resources as compared to our USA private/governmental forms of healthcare delivery? Let me know what you think. ..Maurice.
Monday, February 14, 2005
Gaming the System and Following The AMA Principles of Medical Ethics: What is Ethical?
In order to understand the professional dilemma faced by a physician we should first look at the AMA Principles of Medical Ethics (2001)
How can a physician resolve upholding the standards of professionalism including avoiding engaging in fraud and deception (Principle II) and at the same time “while caring for a patient, regard responsibility to the patient as paramount” (Principle VIII)? Physicians have argued that when a patient needs a test or treatment and the insurance company obstructs then “gaming the system” is deserved in order to do the best for the patient. One could respond, why not respect the law and follow Principle III by trying to change the system. Well, what about that patient that needs attention now? It is a difficult dilemma and as you can see by the study in AJOB noted in my last posting both physicians and patients appear to be motivated to engage in gaming.
Another ethical concern which places a professinal conflict between Principle VIII and the Principles of VII and IX is related to the suggestion that because of the need for cost containment and sheparding of scarce resources there should be encouragement of bedside rationing. I’ll put up a resource discussion on that topic later. ..Maurice.
Preamble:
The medical profession has long subscribed to a body of ethical statements developed primarily for the benefit of the patient. As a member of this profession, a physician must recognize responsibility to patients first and foremost, as well as to society, to other health professionals, and to self. The following Principles adopted by the American Medical Association are not laws, but standards of conduct which define the essentials of honorable behavior for the physician.
I. A physician shall be dedicated to providing competent medical care, with compassion and respect for human dignity and rights.
II. A physician shall uphold the standards of professionalism, be honest in all professional interactions, and strive to report physicians deficient in character or competence, or engaging in fraud or deception, to appropriate entities.
III. A physician shall respect the law and also recognize a responsibility to seek changes in those requirements which are contrary to the best interests of the patient.
IV. A physician shall respect the rights of patients, colleagues, and other health professionals, and shall safeguard patient confidences and privacy within the constraints of the law.
V. A physician shall continue to study, apply, and advance scientific knowledge, maintain a commitment to medical education, make relevant information available to patients, colleagues, and the public, obtain consultation, and use the talents of other health professionals when indicated.
VI. A physician shall, in the provision of appropriate patient care, except in emergencies, be free to choose whom to serve, with whom to associate, and the environment in which to provide medical care.
VII. A physician shall recognize a responsibility to participate in activities contributing to the improvement of the community and the betterment of public health.
VIII. A physician shall, while caring for a patient, regard responsibility to the patient as paramount.
IX. A physician shall support access to medical care for all people.
How can a physician resolve upholding the standards of professionalism including avoiding engaging in fraud and deception (Principle II) and at the same time “while caring for a patient, regard responsibility to the patient as paramount” (Principle VIII)? Physicians have argued that when a patient needs a test or treatment and the insurance company obstructs then “gaming the system” is deserved in order to do the best for the patient. One could respond, why not respect the law and follow Principle III by trying to change the system. Well, what about that patient that needs attention now? It is a difficult dilemma and as you can see by the study in AJOB noted in my last posting both physicians and patients appear to be motivated to engage in gaming.
Another ethical concern which places a professinal conflict between Principle VIII and the Principles of VII and IX is related to the suggestion that because of the need for cost containment and sheparding of scarce resources there should be encouragement of bedside rationing. I’ll put up a resource discussion on that topic later. ..Maurice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)