Let’s get down to brass tacks regarding miracles in medicine. We need to review the ethics of an issue physicians can face in their career. Patients and their families are looking for miracle cures when the illness has been treated, the treatment and additional treatment fails or as in the case of some diseases, such as symptomatic rabies, there is no treatment but only death. And the patient or their family will look at the physician and say “how about trying…?”, “I read about..”, “What else can you prescribe..?” How should the physician respond when the physician suspects the prognosis is nil. Should the physician respond frankly with “I have done all I can do.. there is nothing else to do for a cure.. but I can make you comfortable..”? Or should the physician under pressure from the patient and family not give up and perhaps concur with their requests or recommend a treatment that is unproven? After all, is there anything to lose? This action will demonstrate to the patient and family that the physician has their true interest at heart, he or she has listened to them and is willing to enter this adventure with them. Should this make the physician feel more comfortable and have no regrets regarding the outcome? Would the comfort also extend to the idea that there might be less chance for malpractice liability as initiated by the family?
But what is there to lose? What about providing an unproven therapy? Is there a scientific or an ethical rationale for experimenting a theory on a single patient? If the response is successful, what does this prove? And if not? Or does this not matter? What are the burdens to the use of unproven therapy in such cases as I have described? Would the toxicity kill the patient and not the underlying disease? Or should we look at the harms of treatment as irrelevant if the benefit is a miraculous recovery? What are other potential losses we can consider? How about an element of the profession of medicine that deals with society’s understanding that physicians practice under scientific principles and not as some irrational “witch doctor”? Would medicine lose society’s respect? And another question: who will pay for the unproven treatment? This deals also with justice and shepherding scarce resources such as providing that care and treatment is available to other patients? Would patients lose something they need by the act of utilizing unproven treatment on another patient?
Many questions but what are the answers? Miracles are miracles because they may be hoped for but realistically never expected to happen and if occurring are simply unexplainable. How far, if ever, should physicians go to reach for a miracle? ..Maurice.
Sunday, June 26, 2005
Saturday, June 25, 2005
More on Medical Miracles
I think the discussion of medical miracles which has been going on in the Comment section of my last post is worthy of publishing as a new post. And so here it is...
..Maurice.
At Wed Jun 22, 07:29:19 PM 2005, Maurice Bernstein, M.D. said...
For those interested in music therapy, there is the website of the Healing Music Organization. The organization is described as follows: "The Healing Music Organization (HMO) provides information, resources, tools, and a forum for dialogue to people interested in the healing power of sound and music. The Healing Music Organization serves as a bridge between the worlds of spirituality, art, and medicine by honoring the value of each modality. We support the concept of miracles in healing when the body, mind and spirit learn to harmonize together and resonate with the vast energy of the universe." Some interesting research results regarding music, sound and vibration are described on the site.
There is no doubt that music plays a major role in our life from iPod, dance parties, concerts and even "elevator music". As with poetry and humor, it is hard to know to what extent these media are truely therapeutic for disease as a part of alternate therapy in the individual patient. But since they all, in a proper titration, often appear to relieve stress, that in itself is a good. ..Maurice.
At Thu Jun 23, 12:24:38 PM 2005, Bob Koepp said...
Music, poety, dance, close friendships -- all these and many more have a place in helping us to maintain or recover our health. But miracles? I have a few problems here, not the least of which is trying to get clear about just what a miracle is.
For example, the Healing Music Organization that Maurice mentions seems to view miracles as somehow related to what can happen "when the body, mind and spirit learn to harmonize together and resonate with the vast energy of the universe." Let's suppose that such harmonic resonance actually occurs, and actually correlates with healing not otherwise attributable to medical interventions or the natural restorative, regenerative capacities of organisms. Wouldn't the assumed connection to getting into the "universal groove" suggest that there's something wholly natural (i.e., non-miraculous) taking place?
Just wondering.
At Thu Jun 23, 05:21:01 PM 2005, Alyssa Uphoff said...
The birth of a baby is “wholly natural” but do we think that it is inappropriate for parents to call the new addition their “little miracle”?
In my experience, the feeling that something is miraculous (or not) is entirely up to the individual. The same exact event can be viewed by multiple people: for one: it may be a miracle, for another: serendipity, you: a scientific or natural course of events. I don’t think that we should discount patients, or their families, when they believe a miracle has occurred or are hoping for one to occur. If a person with cancer improves and goes into remission, someone might say that it is thanks to the chemo, radiation, surgery, or some other treatment. For someone else, that can be a miraculous event. A woman was sure she would die, but she didn’t. Maybe she believes God worked through the medicine. Or touched her divinely and healed her. I don’t think that anyone should try to take that from her.
I think that it is more complicated when serious injury and terminal conditions are on the line. Very often in a consultation, after a lengthy discussion regarding why it a certain treatment was no longer helping, a patient’s family member can see that they are losing ground in the fight to “save” the patient, and will look at the physician and say, “But doctor, don’t you believe in miracles?” Almost every doctor I know said, “No.” For many people in the medical community, the word miracle is extremely dangerous. Families sometimes use their hope for a miracle recovery as ammunition to keep a patient on artificial treatments, even when there is insurmountable evidence that their loved one will not survive, will never again regain consciousness, that a limb must be amputated, etc., etc.
In my opinion, discounting a person’s hope for a miracle is an insensitive and unwise move. So what if it is illogical and unreasonable? While illness can be academically internalized by those people on the treatment team, many families feel like they are lost and outnumbered. They are pushed to make life and death decisions that for which they are not prepared. They cannot get their way with an academically fueled battle, so they bring out the irrational “miracle.” I found though that acknowledging their hope helped us make more headway. If you open up the discussion of hope and spirituality then the family can sometimes feel less alienated and angry.
At Thu Jun 23, 08:28:38 PM 2005, Bob Koepp said...
I certainly didn't intend to suggest that there aren't very many interesting and valuable perspectives from which people can view events. And of course people apply the term 'miracle' to all sorts of events. I'm even quite willing to explore the therapeutic value of harmonic resonances, an idea at least as old as Pythagoras.
But there's also a long and sordid history of miraculous cures and flim flam that plays on the vulnerabilities of sick people. When an organization endorses the "concept of miracles in healing", it is time to be vigilant.
At Thu Jun 23, 08:59:15 PM 2005, Alyssa Uphoff said...
I agree that the way that HMO characterized their mission seems to play on those vulnerabilities.
..Maurice.
At Wed Jun 22, 07:29:19 PM 2005, Maurice Bernstein, M.D. said...
For those interested in music therapy, there is the website of the Healing Music Organization. The organization is described as follows: "The Healing Music Organization (HMO) provides information, resources, tools, and a forum for dialogue to people interested in the healing power of sound and music. The Healing Music Organization serves as a bridge between the worlds of spirituality, art, and medicine by honoring the value of each modality. We support the concept of miracles in healing when the body, mind and spirit learn to harmonize together and resonate with the vast energy of the universe." Some interesting research results regarding music, sound and vibration are described on the site.
There is no doubt that music plays a major role in our life from iPod, dance parties, concerts and even "elevator music". As with poetry and humor, it is hard to know to what extent these media are truely therapeutic for disease as a part of alternate therapy in the individual patient. But since they all, in a proper titration, often appear to relieve stress, that in itself is a good. ..Maurice.
At Thu Jun 23, 12:24:38 PM 2005, Bob Koepp said...
Music, poety, dance, close friendships -- all these and many more have a place in helping us to maintain or recover our health. But miracles? I have a few problems here, not the least of which is trying to get clear about just what a miracle is.
For example, the Healing Music Organization that Maurice mentions seems to view miracles as somehow related to what can happen "when the body, mind and spirit learn to harmonize together and resonate with the vast energy of the universe." Let's suppose that such harmonic resonance actually occurs, and actually correlates with healing not otherwise attributable to medical interventions or the natural restorative, regenerative capacities of organisms. Wouldn't the assumed connection to getting into the "universal groove" suggest that there's something wholly natural (i.e., non-miraculous) taking place?
Just wondering.
At Thu Jun 23, 05:21:01 PM 2005, Alyssa Uphoff said...
The birth of a baby is “wholly natural” but do we think that it is inappropriate for parents to call the new addition their “little miracle”?
In my experience, the feeling that something is miraculous (or not) is entirely up to the individual. The same exact event can be viewed by multiple people: for one: it may be a miracle, for another: serendipity, you: a scientific or natural course of events. I don’t think that we should discount patients, or their families, when they believe a miracle has occurred or are hoping for one to occur. If a person with cancer improves and goes into remission, someone might say that it is thanks to the chemo, radiation, surgery, or some other treatment. For someone else, that can be a miraculous event. A woman was sure she would die, but she didn’t. Maybe she believes God worked through the medicine. Or touched her divinely and healed her. I don’t think that anyone should try to take that from her.
I think that it is more complicated when serious injury and terminal conditions are on the line. Very often in a consultation, after a lengthy discussion regarding why it a certain treatment was no longer helping, a patient’s family member can see that they are losing ground in the fight to “save” the patient, and will look at the physician and say, “But doctor, don’t you believe in miracles?” Almost every doctor I know said, “No.” For many people in the medical community, the word miracle is extremely dangerous. Families sometimes use their hope for a miracle recovery as ammunition to keep a patient on artificial treatments, even when there is insurmountable evidence that their loved one will not survive, will never again regain consciousness, that a limb must be amputated, etc., etc.
In my opinion, discounting a person’s hope for a miracle is an insensitive and unwise move. So what if it is illogical and unreasonable? While illness can be academically internalized by those people on the treatment team, many families feel like they are lost and outnumbered. They are pushed to make life and death decisions that for which they are not prepared. They cannot get their way with an academically fueled battle, so they bring out the irrational “miracle.” I found though that acknowledging their hope helped us make more headway. If you open up the discussion of hope and spirituality then the family can sometimes feel less alienated and angry.
At Thu Jun 23, 08:28:38 PM 2005, Bob Koepp said...
I certainly didn't intend to suggest that there aren't very many interesting and valuable perspectives from which people can view events. And of course people apply the term 'miracle' to all sorts of events. I'm even quite willing to explore the therapeutic value of harmonic resonances, an idea at least as old as Pythagoras.
But there's also a long and sordid history of miraculous cures and flim flam that plays on the vulnerabilities of sick people. When an organization endorses the "concept of miracles in healing", it is time to be vigilant.
At Thu Jun 23, 08:59:15 PM 2005, Alyssa Uphoff said...
I agree that the way that HMO characterized their mission seems to play on those vulnerabilities.
Tuesday, June 21, 2005
Poetry in Medicine (2)
Continuing on with this thread, I have found two writings related to the use and benefit of poetry in general medicine and psychiatry. With regard primarily to its use in psychiatry read "Poetry as Therapy" by Perie J. Longo, PhD.
In Poetry As Healer, Deborah L. Shelton, covers some of the history and research into the use of poetry as therapy. Also, the experience of Dr.Rafael Campo is quoted as in this excerpt:
Thinking about all this, I wrote the following poem. Maybe it will be therapeutic to someone.
Woeful Toeful
There once was a man who'd shout
"I have this God-awful gout!"
His Doc wrote this rhyme,
That he repeated time after time,
And his gout just faded out, faded out.
Anyone want to try to write another poem? ..Maurice.
In Poetry As Healer, Deborah L. Shelton, covers some of the history and research into the use of poetry as therapy. Also, the experience of Dr.Rafael Campo is quoted as in this excerpt:
"I can't tell you how many times patients have come in and said a poem has changed their understanding of the experience [of their illness]," said Rafael Campo, MD, assistant professor of internal medicine at Beth Israel-Deaconess Medical Center. "Poetry has the power to say that others have been through this, that you can live with it too." As a physician-poet, he understands the importance of that message. For example, "a breast cancer diagnosis is a terrifying experience for many people," said Dr. Campo, who discusses poetry with about a third of his patients. "But here's something -- a poem -- that will give a different perspective on the experience. You're engaging the patient and letting them know you see them as a whole person and not just a lump in a breast."
… Poetry can facilitate effective communication and empathy, said Dr. Campo. And that's an important part of being a good doctor. "Empathic care providers provide the best care to patients, and poetry is a useful means for exploring empathy and forming those connections with patients," he said.
Thinking about all this, I wrote the following poem. Maybe it will be therapeutic to someone.
Woeful Toeful
There once was a man who'd shout
"I have this God-awful gout!"
His Doc wrote this rhyme,
That he repeated time after time,
And his gout just faded out, faded out.
Anyone want to try to write another poem? ..Maurice.
Monday, June 20, 2005
Poetry in Medicine
Recent previous postings dealt with the possible role of humor in medicine. I would like to bring up the topic now of poetry in medicine and what it may represent. As many of you know, publication of poems relating to medicine is a regular feature in the Journal of the American Medical Association. What is it about medicine and disease that stimulates poetry writing and what effect does reading such poems carry? I found one discussion of the topic in
Community Ethics , the Newsletter of the Consortium Ethics Program of the University of Pittsburgh titled “Why Poetry in Health Care?” and written by Eugene Hirsch, M.D. Here is an excerpt. Notice how writing poetry by this physician has provided him with a means of expressing what to him is most meaningful in his medical practice.
I suppose most poets write for more esoteric reasons. But, as a physician, I wanted to learn to come to terms with life without trying to control it - at least enough to resist losing my identity through the absorbing seduction of impersonal medical technology. Some physicians are fulfilled by centering their lives around tangible problems and systems rather than the intangible nuances which accompany long term interactions with people and their functioning. Indeed, in taking nebulous paths, I sometimes think I have failed in important aspects of medicine. With my limited ability to follow tangible guideposts in the rapid fire of clinical processing, I have gravitated toward patients with altered function and chronic medical problems rather than acute ones, keeping company with my geriatrician peers and with the imaginations of philosophers and English teachers. Indeed, I have wondered how it is that as humans we tend so well to fostering value-free hard science, yet seem so helpless in stimulating value-laden, humanistic progress in our affective and societal selves.
What does writing poetry accomplish for the writer whether a physician or a patient? Clearly, at least it provides a means of emotional ventilation that can be considered therapeutic to whatever the role of the author. I think also it becomes an educational tool for the reader, in that aspects of being a patient or treating a patient which may previously have been unrecognized by the reader can now become apparent. And with that knowledge, the reader will be more understanding of medical issues that will be personally encountered later.
Let me give you my comments about what I think is the medical value of poems such as the following two which were written and posted here by me last year.
July 22, 2004-
Unspoken Translation
by Maurice Bernstein, M.D.
“I have this”
She talked through a translator with a language I don’t know
“And it burns”
She pulls up her shirt and points to her kidney
“I am worried”
Why? I ask through a translator
“I am unmarried and have a small child”
Are you worried about your kidney? The translator speaks for me
Tears fill her eyes and move down her cheeks and
I don’t need a translator to tell me more.
This poem was based on a recent patient encounter. I have been frustrated by the need and process of translation as a means of communicating with patients. I wanted to show that there are times when empathetic observation can be sufficient to understand the patient.
August 29, 2004-
Uninvited Guest
By Maurice Bernstein, M.D.
Oh, Culex, you uninvited guest
Who kissed me, spreading your exotic gift
And leaving me weak, feverish, seeing double
And becoming suddenly a modern statistic.
Oh, Culex, where are you now?
What life are you going to challenge next?
Stay away. I'll be back.
And, you know, Culex, I have never been to Uganda.
Here I was sickened by West Nile virus infection and frustrated and angry by the degree of sickness from some small creature without any warning to which I could not react. As a patient, I wanted to ventilate my anger and I think I did this, in part, through writing this poem as I returned from the hospital.
What is your take on poetry in medicine? And do you have a poem to share you wrote as a healthcare provider or that came from you or someone else as a patient? ..Maurice.
Community Ethics , the Newsletter of the Consortium Ethics Program of the University of Pittsburgh titled “Why Poetry in Health Care?” and written by Eugene Hirsch, M.D. Here is an excerpt. Notice how writing poetry by this physician has provided him with a means of expressing what to him is most meaningful in his medical practice.
I suppose most poets write for more esoteric reasons. But, as a physician, I wanted to learn to come to terms with life without trying to control it - at least enough to resist losing my identity through the absorbing seduction of impersonal medical technology. Some physicians are fulfilled by centering their lives around tangible problems and systems rather than the intangible nuances which accompany long term interactions with people and their functioning. Indeed, in taking nebulous paths, I sometimes think I have failed in important aspects of medicine. With my limited ability to follow tangible guideposts in the rapid fire of clinical processing, I have gravitated toward patients with altered function and chronic medical problems rather than acute ones, keeping company with my geriatrician peers and with the imaginations of philosophers and English teachers. Indeed, I have wondered how it is that as humans we tend so well to fostering value-free hard science, yet seem so helpless in stimulating value-laden, humanistic progress in our affective and societal selves.
What does writing poetry accomplish for the writer whether a physician or a patient? Clearly, at least it provides a means of emotional ventilation that can be considered therapeutic to whatever the role of the author. I think also it becomes an educational tool for the reader, in that aspects of being a patient or treating a patient which may previously have been unrecognized by the reader can now become apparent. And with that knowledge, the reader will be more understanding of medical issues that will be personally encountered later.
Let me give you my comments about what I think is the medical value of poems such as the following two which were written and posted here by me last year.
July 22, 2004-
Unspoken Translation
by Maurice Bernstein, M.D.
“I have this”
She talked through a translator with a language I don’t know
“And it burns”
She pulls up her shirt and points to her kidney
“I am worried”
Why? I ask through a translator
“I am unmarried and have a small child”
Are you worried about your kidney? The translator speaks for me
Tears fill her eyes and move down her cheeks and
I don’t need a translator to tell me more.
This poem was based on a recent patient encounter. I have been frustrated by the need and process of translation as a means of communicating with patients. I wanted to show that there are times when empathetic observation can be sufficient to understand the patient.
August 29, 2004-
Uninvited Guest
By Maurice Bernstein, M.D.
Oh, Culex, you uninvited guest
Who kissed me, spreading your exotic gift
And leaving me weak, feverish, seeing double
And becoming suddenly a modern statistic.
Oh, Culex, where are you now?
What life are you going to challenge next?
Stay away. I'll be back.
And, you know, Culex, I have never been to Uganda.
Here I was sickened by West Nile virus infection and frustrated and angry by the degree of sickness from some small creature without any warning to which I could not react. As a patient, I wanted to ventilate my anger and I think I did this, in part, through writing this poem as I returned from the hospital.
What is your take on poetry in medicine? And do you have a poem to share you wrote as a healthcare provider or that came from you or someone else as a patient? ..Maurice.
Sunday, June 19, 2005
More Hippocratic Aphorisms
Aphorism is a short, pithy statement of an evident truth concerned with life or nature. Hippocrates wrote a series of aphorisms on medical practice. They became handy hints for the physicians of the time (400 BCE). Perhaps they represented a tool analogous to what medical interns have carried around in their pockets—the Merck Manual. Many aphorisms dealt with the art of purging since very few other treatments were available then. Prognostication between curable and incurable conditions was a common issue in the aphorisms. The first Hippocratic aphorisms was the topic of the last posting. Here are some more aphorisms of a general nature as extracted from http://classics.mit.edu. To read a translation of them all go to the link.
Aphorisms by Hippocrates and translated by Francis Adams
Section II-19.-In acute diseases it is not quite safe to prognosticate either death or recovery.
Section II-33. In every disease it is a good sign when the patient's intellect is sound, and he is disposed to take whatever food is offered to him; but the contrary is bad.
Section II-44. Persons who are naturally very fat are apt to die earlier than those who are slender.
Section II-52 When doing everything according to indications, although things may not turn out agreeably to indication, we should not change to another while the original appearances remain.
Section VII-43. A woman does not become ambidextrous.
Section VII-87. Those diseases, which medicines do not cure, iron (the knife?) cures; those which iron cannot cure, fire cures; and those which fire cannot cure, are to be reckoned wholly incurable.
Any comments on your interpretation of the significance of these views of Hippocrates? ..Maurice.
Aphorisms by Hippocrates and translated by Francis Adams
Section II-19.-In acute diseases it is not quite safe to prognosticate either death or recovery.
Section II-33. In every disease it is a good sign when the patient's intellect is sound, and he is disposed to take whatever food is offered to him; but the contrary is bad.
Section II-44. Persons who are naturally very fat are apt to die earlier than those who are slender.
Section II-52 When doing everything according to indications, although things may not turn out agreeably to indication, we should not change to another while the original appearances remain.
Section VII-43. A woman does not become ambidextrous.
Section VII-87. Those diseases, which medicines do not cure, iron (the knife?) cures; those which iron cannot cure, fire cures; and those which fire cannot cure, are to be reckoned wholly incurable.
Any comments on your interpretation of the significance of these views of Hippocrates? ..Maurice.
Saturday, June 18, 2005
“Too Little Life, Too Much Medicine"
Bioethicist Albert R. Jonsen, Ph.D., Professor Emeritus of Ethics in Medicine, School of Medicine at the University of Washington gave a talk day before yesterday at UCLA titled “Too Little Life, Too Much Medicine” in which he dissected the First Aphorism of Hippocrates in terms of modern medicine and the futility debate. I thought it would be valuable to give a little thought to this reinterpretation by Dr. Jonsen. The following is based directly on the talk and handout.
The First Aphorism of Hippocrates reads “Life is short; the art is long. Opportunity is fleeting, experience perilous and judgment is difficult. The physician must be ready, not only to do his duty himself, but to secure the cooperation of the patient, attendants and of externals.” The Classic Interpretation was that “one’s life is too short to learn all one needs to know about medicine. Therefore, take chances, don’t rely on experience and take responsibility for the consequences.”
Dr. Jonsen’s reinterpretation for modern medicine includes:
“Human life, not the doctor’s life, is always too short. [There are always doctors around.] There is always plenty of medical science and skill. The nature of science and technology is [considered] infinite and infallible. Therefore sometimes there is more medicine than life can bear.”
The point of the lecture, I think, was to remind us all is that medical technology has developed to such an extent in maintaining life, that just because technology has the potential to do what it can do is reason in itself to always employ it despite any other factors which might warrant its non-use. I can think of the current example of the case of Terri Schiavo, where the technology of being able to provide a life-sustaining potion of fluid and nutriments to someone who is unable to swallow on their own and can maintain life is reason enough to continue this technology in the patient even in the face of permanent unconsciousness and unawareness. One can see this irrational use of medical technology in other examples of treatments which will not achieve the goal the patient might have wanted but because it is there, use it! The push to use it comes from patients, families and even the companies that developed the technology or drug. And, under pressure from them, the physician may throw experience away and prescribe the therapy.
I didn’t read Dr. Jonsen as advocating diminishing the progression of the advancement of science and technology but just warning us of the possibility of its ethically non-beneficent effects in medical practice. ..Maurice.
The First Aphorism of Hippocrates reads “Life is short; the art is long. Opportunity is fleeting, experience perilous and judgment is difficult. The physician must be ready, not only to do his duty himself, but to secure the cooperation of the patient, attendants and of externals.” The Classic Interpretation was that “one’s life is too short to learn all one needs to know about medicine. Therefore, take chances, don’t rely on experience and take responsibility for the consequences.”
Dr. Jonsen’s reinterpretation for modern medicine includes:
“Human life, not the doctor’s life, is always too short. [There are always doctors around.] There is always plenty of medical science and skill. The nature of science and technology is [considered] infinite and infallible. Therefore sometimes there is more medicine than life can bear.”
The point of the lecture, I think, was to remind us all is that medical technology has developed to such an extent in maintaining life, that just because technology has the potential to do what it can do is reason in itself to always employ it despite any other factors which might warrant its non-use. I can think of the current example of the case of Terri Schiavo, where the technology of being able to provide a life-sustaining potion of fluid and nutriments to someone who is unable to swallow on their own and can maintain life is reason enough to continue this technology in the patient even in the face of permanent unconsciousness and unawareness. One can see this irrational use of medical technology in other examples of treatments which will not achieve the goal the patient might have wanted but because it is there, use it! The push to use it comes from patients, families and even the companies that developed the technology or drug. And, under pressure from them, the physician may throw experience away and prescribe the therapy.
I didn’t read Dr. Jonsen as advocating diminishing the progression of the advancement of science and technology but just warning us of the possibility of its ethically non-beneficent effects in medical practice. ..Maurice.
Thursday, June 16, 2005
Medical Decisions: In Whose Best Interest at End-of-Life and PVS?
Today, on ABC’s “Good Morning America”, physician and Senator Bill Frist commenting on the autopsy results of Terri Schiavo said “She had devastating brain damage, and with that, the chapter's closed." But is the chapter really closed?
Today, Gov. Jeb Bush said he might ask a state attorney to investigate allegations that Terri Schiavo's husband waited more than an hour to call 911 after her 1990 collapse.
Today, Terri Schiavo's brother Bobby Schindler said they knew all along that Terri was profoundly brain damaged but they just wanted to bring her home and take care of her.
And the “right to life” groups are putting pressure on several state houses to write laws to prevent physicians from removing nutrition and hydration from patients.
No, the chapter is not closed.
And I think, neither is an ethical discussion of the Terri Schiavo case a closed chapter. In previous postings, I have brought out the concept of “best interest” in the treatment decisions of patients and have remarked on the issue of “in whose best interest” is a decision being made. This is particularly of note in end-of-life or persistent vegetative state patients. Doctors are taught that their primary interest and fiduciary responsibility is for their patient. And most doctors practice their medicine that way. Of course, they are also taught to consider the psycho-social impact of their patient’s disability on the patient’s family. But it is their patient, whose needs and the attempt to meet the patient’s goals which usually trump all else. The question I want to bring up now and perhaps as a “devils advocate” is whether we should begin to consider seriously changing of the paradigm when the patient is terminally ill or in a permanent vegetative state. Should we, at that point in the patient’s medical course, look seriously at the needs of the family? Should we begin to consider requests and decisions that now might be in the best interest of the family since the patient’s interest as a cognitive person is virtually gone or now gone forever? Would it have been in the best interest of the Schindler family to have allowed them to take home and nurse their heart beating “doll”. For Terri as a person, this would have been irrelevant. Of course, and this is where best interest for the family may not be a simple consideration, Mr. Schiavo may have found that his best interest was to follow what he understood was his wife’s request.
Physicians practice their profession at the desire of society. If society comes to a consensus that they want more consideration of the family’s best interest and their views including medically extra-ordinary treatment or even “right to life” decisions in the terminally ill or persistent vegetative state patients can physicians ignore this request?
..Maurice.
Today, Gov. Jeb Bush said he might ask a state attorney to investigate allegations that Terri Schiavo's husband waited more than an hour to call 911 after her 1990 collapse.
Today, Terri Schiavo's brother Bobby Schindler said they knew all along that Terri was profoundly brain damaged but they just wanted to bring her home and take care of her.
And the “right to life” groups are putting pressure on several state houses to write laws to prevent physicians from removing nutrition and hydration from patients.
No, the chapter is not closed.
And I think, neither is an ethical discussion of the Terri Schiavo case a closed chapter. In previous postings, I have brought out the concept of “best interest” in the treatment decisions of patients and have remarked on the issue of “in whose best interest” is a decision being made. This is particularly of note in end-of-life or persistent vegetative state patients. Doctors are taught that their primary interest and fiduciary responsibility is for their patient. And most doctors practice their medicine that way. Of course, they are also taught to consider the psycho-social impact of their patient’s disability on the patient’s family. But it is their patient, whose needs and the attempt to meet the patient’s goals which usually trump all else. The question I want to bring up now and perhaps as a “devils advocate” is whether we should begin to consider seriously changing of the paradigm when the patient is terminally ill or in a permanent vegetative state. Should we, at that point in the patient’s medical course, look seriously at the needs of the family? Should we begin to consider requests and decisions that now might be in the best interest of the family since the patient’s interest as a cognitive person is virtually gone or now gone forever? Would it have been in the best interest of the Schindler family to have allowed them to take home and nurse their heart beating “doll”. For Terri as a person, this would have been irrelevant. Of course, and this is where best interest for the family may not be a simple consideration, Mr. Schiavo may have found that his best interest was to follow what he understood was his wife’s request.
Physicians practice their profession at the desire of society. If society comes to a consensus that they want more consideration of the family’s best interest and their views including medically extra-ordinary treatment or even “right to life” decisions in the terminally ill or persistent vegetative state patients can physicians ignore this request?
..Maurice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)