Monday, January 16, 2006

More Unethics in Medical Research: Is There Prevention?


From BBC News October 7 2005:

Drugs similar to aspirin reduce the risk of mouth cancer but possibly at a cost to the heart, say researchers.

The Norwegian-led team looked at the cancer protection offered by non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs among nearly 1,000 heavy smokers.

Those drugs cut the risk of oral cancer by more than half - the same as stopping smoking.

However, they also appeared to double the risk of death due to heart disease, the Lancet journal reports.


From the BBC News today January 16, 2006:

Cancer study patients 'made up'

A cancer expert invented patients for a study which concluded taking common painkillers could protect against oral cancer, it is alleged.

Dr Jon Sudbo reportedly made up patients and case histories for the study published in highly-respected Lancet medical journal last October. Dr Sudbo has not commented publicly on the claims.
But a spokeswoman for Oslo's Norwegian Radium Hospital, where he works, said he had admitted falsifying data.

Dr Richard Horton, editor of The Lancet, is attempting to have the paper retracted from the journal. He defends the peer-review process of journals in their goal to prevent poorly designed studies from being published. However, this process is not designed to identify fabricated research. He says "Just as in society you cannot always prevent crime, in science you cannot always prevent fabrication."
One wonders about the motivational forces present in research which lead to unethical behavior in the falsifying of experiments. Is there anything society can do to prevent such behavior? ..Maurice

ADDENDUM 1-16-2006:

There is an excellent article in the August 15 2005 issue of the Boston Globe which describes the controversy as to the results of so-called peer-review of medical research papers. “..after a study that sent reverberations through the medical profession by finding that almost one-third of top research articles have been either contradicted or seriously questioned, some specialists are calling for radical changes in the system.”

The question is how could so many poorly documented studies be accepted for publication in major journals that were later found to be erroneous and yet had been under the scrutiny of peer-review. It seems, according to the article, that there is a lack of public transparency in the peer-review process. Those who were reviewing the peer-review process itself “… found that it was almost impossible to discover what had happened in the vetting process, since peer reviewers are unpaid, anonymous, and unaccountable. Moreover, their reviews are kept confidential, making it impossible to know the parameters of the reviews.”

If the goal of peer-review is to prevent poorly designed studies from being published, granted that this process is not designed to identify fabricated research, then it appears that something is defective in whatever the peer reviewers are trying to accomplish. As the Boston Globe article suggests, there are those who think the whole system of vetting for publication should be overhauled. ..Maurice.

Sunday, January 15, 2006

Ounce of Prevention Worth a Pound of Cure?: When No Prevention and No Cure

“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” so the saying goes. But what happens when there is no means of prevention and there is no effective or permanent cure? In the worldview, I can think of war as one example. In the view of clinical medicine, I can think illnesses of today, which include some degenerative or inflammatory diseases and cancers or isolated symptoms of fatigue or pain as examples where the mechanism of onset is unknown and therefore prevention is unclear and there is no treatment towards an effective cure. As with war, we are committed to simply, for our time being, “live with it.” But how do we do that? And as physicians, what is our role and duty when currently prevention and cure is impossible?

It is important that all students as they learn to be physicians realize that despite all the science they are taught and all the medical gadgetry and procedures that are available, they are going to be faced with patients with such diseases as I described. This may be a hard realization to accept but surely this will repeatedly happen in their careers. The concept that the students must learn is that the role of physicians is not only to prevent and cure disease but to be responsible for ongoing support of the ill patient even with no probability of doing something curative. This is the very hard and frustrating part of being a patient’s physician, particularly if the doctor and patient’s goals are for a cure.

In this kind of illness, the approach should be one of changing the emphasis of the goal to support and attempt at comfort rather than cure and yet not abandoning hope. If this is done well and the patient is comfortable, this treatment can be almost as rewarding to the doctor as a cure.

The burden which the physician needs to realize that he or she may have to bear is that of “living with” the patient’s illness. And “living with” a number of patient’s illnesses is to some physicians intolerable and leads to annoyance with the person as a patient, delaying of patient visits or the transfer of the patient to care of another physician. Hopefully, the hospice concept, the education of physicians with regard to chronic illness, chronic physical and mental disability, pain management and comfort care, there will come a day when “no prevention” and “no cure” will become "no problem”. ..Maurice.

Friday, January 13, 2006

Medical Ethics of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (7)


Back in November 2004, I started writing a series of posts on the medical ethics of complementary and alternative medicine. Because of inadequate management of symptoms by modern medicine and perhaps because of the poor communication skills by modern physicians, many patients are turning to alternative medicine for relief. I found the following “historical” listing of prescriptions for one symptom on several joke websites and thought it reflected some truism about medical treatment through the ages. What do you think? ..Maurice.

A Brief History Of Medicine

I have an earache.

2000 B.C. - Here, eat this root.
1000 A.D. - That root is heathen, say this prayer.
1850 A.D. - That prayer is superstition, drink this potion.
1940 A.D. - That potion is snake oil, swallow this pill.
1985 A.D. - That pill is ineffective, take this antibiotic.
2003 A.D. - That antibiotic is artificial. Here, eat this root.


Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Would You Desire Your End-of-Life Care Managed by a DEA Agent?

A Perspective commentary by Timothy E. Quill, M.D., and Diane E. Meier, M.D. in the January 5th 2006 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine describes the chilling effect on physicians' provision of comfort care of terminally ill patients because of the November 2001 U.S. Attorney General John Ashcroft directive which states that the prescription of Schedule 2 medications under the Oregon law violates the Controlled Substance Act since “assisting in a suicide is not a ‘legitimate medical purpose’” The commentary suggests that “If passed, this directive would allow the federal government to overrule established state law, empower the [Drug Enforcement Agency] DEA to investigate whether a violation had occurred, and potentially open to investigation every instance of prescribing of a controlled substance for a dying patient.” and not simply if administered under Oregon law.

The directive was taken to court by the state of Oregon and others with the argument that it should be the state’s responsibility to determine “legitimate medical purpose” and not the Controlled Substance Act. While the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals supported the Oregon argument, the case was subsequently heard in the U.S. Supreme Court, which has as yet not announced a decision.

The authors conclude: “This type of DEA involvement in medical practice would adversely affect far more patients than those few who seek assistance with a hastened death in Oregon. If the government thus oversteps its legitimate role and expertise, allowing DEA agents, trained only to combat criminal substance abuse and diversion, to dictate to physicians what constitutes acceptable medical practice for seriously ill and dying persons, it will undermine palliative care and pain management for the much larger number of seriously ill patients in all states. Physicians may become hesitant to prescribe the best available medications to manage the pain, agitation, and shortness of breath that sometimes accompany the end stages of illness. As a result, they may, in essence, abandon patients and their families in their moment of the greatest need”

I have no doubt that the dire predictions of Quill and Meier will come true if the directive is sustained. We physicians will not risk jail time or heavy fines for performing humane patient comfort care. Better, society finally decides who sets the standards of practice, the States and their physicians or DEA agents And if the latter, perhaps the DEA agents would want to take over end-of-life patient management themselves. Any sarcastic comments to my sarcastic suggestion? ..Maurice.

Sunday, January 8, 2006

More on Immortality

Joyce Kilmer has humanized trees in this well known poem “Trees”

I think that I shall never see
A poem lovely as a tree,
A tree whose hungry mouth is prest
Against the earth's sweet flowing breast;
A tree that looks at God aft day,
And lifts her leafy arms to pray;
A tree that may in Summer wear
A nest of robins in her hair;
Upon whose bosom snow has lain;
Who intimately lives with rain.
Poems are made by fools like me,
But only God can make a tree.


As I was hiking today through Towsley Canyon in Southern California, I came upon this tree clinging on to the rocky side of a mountain and I wondered if there was a common yearning between man and tree for longevity and/or immortality. Any thoughts? ..Maurice.

Saturday, January 7, 2006

Does Standards of Medical Practice Change for a King? (2)

Continuing with the discussion of VIP medical treatment (Very Important Person medical treatment primarily affected by the importance of the person), based on my clinical knowledge and experience, I can devise a simple scenario that might easily explain the medical predicament that Mr. Sharon's physicians and family now face. I see two factors involved and perhaps both apply.

1) Would it be reasonable to assume that, in response to the thrombotic (? or embolic) CVA in a man with great social importance and responsibility and the great need not to be again incapacitated,his physicians began him on a very energetic anti-coagulation therapy, perhaps 2 or more drugs started together without careful and more prolonged monitoring of the effects of the individual pharmacologic agents?

2) Mr. Sharon, after the ischemic event, felt well and because of his personal strong will and need to resume his governmental and political functions, was not as willing as some other person to remain under careful daily anti-coagulation monitoring, couldn't find time for the necessary venipunctures and, of course, his physicians may have been psychologically oriented or pressured by Sharon's colleagues not to interfere with the "strong man". And so.. the consequence: massive cerebral hemorrhage due to inappropriate anti-coagulation program and/or inadequate monitoring of the anti-coagulation.

The scenario could be as simple as that and behind the whole story was the VIP medical treatment. Again, I must make this disclaimer--this is only a reasonable possible scenario since obviously I don't know the clinical facts.
Will we ever know if this is what happened? If we will and the scenario is correct, this should add more weight against the practice of VIP medical management that to me seems, generally, not at all beneficent to the patient. ..Maurice.

Friday, January 6, 2006

Does Standards of Medical Practice Change for a King?

From Bloomberg news today: "Stroke specialists in the U.S. judged Sharon's prognosis as poor, given the information announced about his condition yesterday. David S. Liebeskind, associate neurology director of the stroke center at the University of California at Los Angeles, said Sharon's chances of full recovery are low.
The benefits of surgery to reduce pressure on the brain are unclear, said Robert D. Brown Jr., professor of neurology and chairman of the stroke division at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota.
``We still don't have good evidence that surgical treatment of hemorrhagic strokes will have an effect on survival or disability,'' Brown said. "


Today, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon apparently underwent his 3rd brain surgery for cerebral bleeding. In view of what appears to be a dismal prognosis and even though the public doesn't know all the clinical details nor the requests of the Sharon family, I would like to pose an ethical issue: should standards of medical practice be guided by the social importance of the patient and not by clinical experience and evidence-based medicine? If other factors are equal, such as ability to afford the medical care, should standard and accepted therapy be trumped by a "do everything and anything" attempts at therapy simply because the patient is a king or a prime minister and not a plain citizen? Again, we have no proof that this is the case with Mr. Sharon.. but I just wondered about justice and non-malificence and so on. ..Maurice.

1/6/2006 ADDENDUM: I just thought of another question: Do you think that V.I.P. (very important person) treatment is a standard of medical practice? If so.. my original question is moot. ..Maurice.