Monday, May 30, 2005
Viagra/Sex Offenders:"Leave prescriptions to the doctor"
Laura Berman, Ph.D., is a sex therapist, director of Chicago's Berman Center writing her column in the Chicago Sun- Times supports my view about physicians prescribing Viagra to former sex-offenders. Dr. Berman writes: "In my clinical experience, healthy sexual encounters are actually a key part of a sex offender's successful recovery. They teach the sex offender to refocus his desire on an appropriate subject. Some convicted sex offenders have been in treatment for decades, with no recidivism. To deny them access to a normal sex life -- as refusing them treatment for erectile dysfunction would do -- would be counterproductive. Rather than aiding and abetting a sex offender, it's more likely that Viagra is being prescribed to those in a healthy, consensual relationship who are experiencing erectile dysfunction." She encourages that physicians, aware of the patient's prior sexual behavior, do the prescribing to the individual patient and not the politicians. ..Maurice.
Friday, May 27, 2005
Viagra/Sexual Offenders:Is the Government Going Off "Half-Cocked"?
Is it possible that our government, in response to the current
brouhaha about Viagra prescriptions to former sexual offenders, is initially behaving
like our government did in the Terri Schiavo case.. first acting out of their
"heart" and not from using their "brains"? Because what is really needed is
a little biology instead of gross politics.
It is very important, in order to
understand whether the ethical principles of beneficience and justice are
being denied some or all of these former offenders, to know what is understood as
to the pathogenesis of their illegal behavior and whether the behavior was
related to either organic or psychologic erectile dysfunction. Specifically,
whether these men have had problems with the ability to attain or maintain an
erection which then led to impaired socially acceptable sexual activity. I have
read that most of the molestation of children is manifiested by fondling
rather than penetration. Could this be an important fact? In cases of rape of
adults, do we know that normal penetration has occurred in most cases? What
symptoms did the former sex offenders present to their physicians and what were the
physical findings that led to a prescription being written for Viagra? Maybe correcting the erectile problem will mitigate the illegal behavioral problem? I really don't know. But someone may or will know.
Therefore, it may be wrong (and for the affected patients non-beneficent and unjust) to just assume that because Viagra is used in sexual activities, it will stimulate the wrong sexual behavior and therefore some patients should not be able to receive it--at government expense or even otherwise. My suggestion is that these and other questions should be answered by those who know and our government shouldn't be going
off "half-cocked"...so to speak. ..Maurice.
Addendum 5-28-2005: Just in case you didn’t think about it, as a consequence of the findings that sex-offenders in many states were receiving Viagra through Medicaid, Congress is now preparing to terminate Medicaid payments for erectile dysfunction medication. This would deny effective medication for the poor to engage in a healthy family behavior thus go against the declared administration goal to encourage family values. And curiously, in addition, this act would likely prevent potential pregnancies and therefore go against the declared administration goal to promote life. Oh well, there is no consistency to politics. ..Maurice.
brouhaha about Viagra prescriptions to former sexual offenders, is initially behaving
like our government did in the Terri Schiavo case.. first acting out of their
"heart" and not from using their "brains"? Because what is really needed is
a little biology instead of gross politics.
It is very important, in order to
understand whether the ethical principles of beneficience and justice are
being denied some or all of these former offenders, to know what is understood as
to the pathogenesis of their illegal behavior and whether the behavior was
related to either organic or psychologic erectile dysfunction. Specifically,
whether these men have had problems with the ability to attain or maintain an
erection which then led to impaired socially acceptable sexual activity. I have
read that most of the molestation of children is manifiested by fondling
rather than penetration. Could this be an important fact? In cases of rape of
adults, do we know that normal penetration has occurred in most cases? What
symptoms did the former sex offenders present to their physicians and what were the
physical findings that led to a prescription being written for Viagra? Maybe correcting the erectile problem will mitigate the illegal behavioral problem? I really don't know. But someone may or will know.
Therefore, it may be wrong (and for the affected patients non-beneficent and unjust) to just assume that because Viagra is used in sexual activities, it will stimulate the wrong sexual behavior and therefore some patients should not be able to receive it--at government expense or even otherwise. My suggestion is that these and other questions should be answered by those who know and our government shouldn't be going
off "half-cocked"...so to speak. ..Maurice.
Addendum 5-28-2005: Just in case you didn’t think about it, as a consequence of the findings that sex-offenders in many states were receiving Viagra through Medicaid, Congress is now preparing to terminate Medicaid payments for erectile dysfunction medication. This would deny effective medication for the poor to engage in a healthy family behavior thus go against the declared administration goal to encourage family values. And curiously, in addition, this act would likely prevent potential pregnancies and therefore go against the declared administration goal to promote life. Oh well, there is no consistency to politics. ..Maurice.
Wednesday, May 25, 2005
President Bush: How Do You Explain Two Issues?
Mr. President Bush, I’ve got two issues to pick with you and I would appreciate hearing the answers. I have been thinking about them for the past several days and lo and behold, the questions popped up today on a bioethics listserv to which I subscribe. Perhaps you will be able to explain them to me and us in non-political terms. OK? [Note: Each issue was written by a separate ethicist and I have excerpted their words, in quotes, in a way to fit the context of my posting but the meaning and significance of their questions are unchanged.]
If you are “so concerned with embryos why is no one trying to make it illegal for IVF clinics to destroy embryos in the first place? Shouldn't they be up in arms about that if they are opposed to using them for research? … if this concern for embryos were well thought out, the same people would want to require that all ‘leftover’ embryos be adopted and implanted or at least not destroyed.”
And the other issue..
President Bush, you seem to be against the concept, as the listserv writer put it, “the noble aspiration [finding cures through use of embryonic stem cells] to justify the
ignoble action [killing of 'our embryonic cousins']. … No matter how promising the
ends, we must not use immoral means to achieve them.”
Now, Mr. Bush, might you not apply your, as the listserv writer continued, “strict moral principle as well to real-live
human beings - say, with regard to the killing in a ‘preemptive’ war,
as in Iraq.”? “Substitute the word ‘Iraq’ for ‘embryonic stem cells:’
‘The noble aspiration [finding weapons of mass destruction, deposing
a dictator, saving future lives - whatever one that's au courant] to
justify the ignoble action [killing and destroying the lives of
innocent Iraqi citizens, American troops, and others].’ Even if the
full status of personhood were conferred on embryos, why should
conscious human beings living real lives be given less consideration?
How can they be used as means to an end, however worthy?”
Mr. Bush, many others and I would be more understanding of your stand if you could answer these questions and explain the logic. Thanks. ..Maurice.
p.s. I thank my two anonymous ethicists for their fine words which I used for this posting.
If you are “so concerned with embryos why is no one trying to make it illegal for IVF clinics to destroy embryos in the first place? Shouldn't they be up in arms about that if they are opposed to using them for research? … if this concern for embryos were well thought out, the same people would want to require that all ‘leftover’ embryos be adopted and implanted or at least not destroyed.”
And the other issue..
President Bush, you seem to be against the concept, as the listserv writer put it, “the noble aspiration [finding cures through use of embryonic stem cells] to justify the
ignoble action [killing of 'our embryonic cousins']. … No matter how promising the
ends, we must not use immoral means to achieve them.”
Now, Mr. Bush, might you not apply your, as the listserv writer continued, “strict moral principle as well to real-live
human beings - say, with regard to the killing in a ‘preemptive’ war,
as in Iraq.”? “Substitute the word ‘Iraq’ for ‘embryonic stem cells:’
‘The noble aspiration [finding weapons of mass destruction, deposing
a dictator, saving future lives - whatever one that's au courant] to
justify the ignoble action [killing and destroying the lives of
innocent Iraqi citizens, American troops, and others].’ Even if the
full status of personhood were conferred on embryos, why should
conscious human beings living real lives be given less consideration?
How can they be used as means to an end, however worthy?”
Mr. Bush, many others and I would be more understanding of your stand if you could answer these questions and explain the logic. Thanks. ..Maurice.
p.s. I thank my two anonymous ethicists for their fine words which I used for this posting.
Termination of Life-Support Without Patient Request
To clarify my views on life-support described in the last posting, I want to note the situation that I didn’t really include. I wrote that it is my view (and it is the consensus in law and ethics) that a patient with capacity for medical decision-making can request and must be granted termination of life-support. To continue the support against the patient’s wishes could be considered legal battery. What I didn’t write was whether, without the permission of the patient or surrogate, life-support could be removed based on the argument of medical futility. The answer should be no if the life-support is physiologically effective and the patient finds that the current or future quality of life satisfactory since there would exist no futility issue. In an unresolved conflict between physician and patient, the courts must decide. The problem arises when the patient has no capacity to make medical decisions and there is no advance directive, no previous expression of goals and no surrogates. Life-support could be removed from such a patient on the basis that the treatment would not be expected to produce recovery to a state that a “reasonable person” might expect and a hospital ethics committee that included community members confirmed the decision of the physician to terminate treatment. The ethics of this issue is all that simple!?? Any questions? ..Maurice.
Tuesday, May 24, 2005
More On "No Right to Artificial Nutrition and Hydration"
"The most important bioethics litigation in the world today involves a 45-year-old Englishman, Leslie Burke... He isn't asking for very much. Burke has a progressive neurological disease that may one day deprive him of the ability to swallow. If that happens, Burke wants to receive food and water through a tube. Knowing that Britain's National Health Service (NHS) rations care, Burke sued to ensure that he will not be forced to endure death by dehydration against his wishes...
Why do Britain's medical establishment and government insist that Burke be denied a right to decide whether he receives tube-supplied food and water? It all boils down to two concepts that are increasingly intertwined in modern bioethics theory and practice. First is the so-called quality-of-life ethic that presumes to judge the worth of patients' lives according to their mental and physical capacities. Under this view, doctors or bioethicists may judge a life to be of such low quality that it is not worth extending, irrespective of the patient's wishes. The second issue is money -- an especially potent factor for England's increasingly strained socialized medical system."
Writing for the U.K. Weekly Standard and published online by CBS News on May 24, 2005,Wesley J. Smith, a lawyer and well-known spokesperson for the disabled presents his views of the two concepts he notes in the above excerpt. In his column, he expresses the conclusion that this case is even more important than the Terri Schiavo case in that he is concerned that our judicial system which is beginning to look to foreign decisions to guide to U.S. law, may use this British case as a source. ..Maurice.
p.s.- My view is that unless the artificial nutrition and hydration is physiologically futile, which it rarely is, whether this specific treatment is started or removed should be the patient's own decision after comparing the risks vs the quality of life to be gained. I think food and fluid decisions should be that of the patient and in all cases requests should be followed by the healthcare providers. There may be medical resistance to starting other life-supporting treatments if the physician finds the medical benefit to be nil, such as beginning dialysis in a terminal cancer patient. There may be special circumstances, such as temporary prolongation of life, which would make starting them appropriate. All life-supportive treatments should also be stopped at the patient's request. Beyond life-supportive treatments, other treatments requested by the patient should be subject to medical standards of practice.
Why do Britain's medical establishment and government insist that Burke be denied a right to decide whether he receives tube-supplied food and water? It all boils down to two concepts that are increasingly intertwined in modern bioethics theory and practice. First is the so-called quality-of-life ethic that presumes to judge the worth of patients' lives according to their mental and physical capacities. Under this view, doctors or bioethicists may judge a life to be of such low quality that it is not worth extending, irrespective of the patient's wishes. The second issue is money -- an especially potent factor for England's increasingly strained socialized medical system."
Writing for the U.K. Weekly Standard and published online by CBS News on May 24, 2005,Wesley J. Smith, a lawyer and well-known spokesperson for the disabled presents his views of the two concepts he notes in the above excerpt. In his column, he expresses the conclusion that this case is even more important than the Terri Schiavo case in that he is concerned that our judicial system which is beginning to look to foreign decisions to guide to U.S. law, may use this British case as a source. ..Maurice.
p.s.- My view is that unless the artificial nutrition and hydration is physiologically futile, which it rarely is, whether this specific treatment is started or removed should be the patient's own decision after comparing the risks vs the quality of life to be gained. I think food and fluid decisions should be that of the patient and in all cases requests should be followed by the healthcare providers. There may be medical resistance to starting other life-supporting treatments if the physician finds the medical benefit to be nil, such as beginning dialysis in a terminal cancer patient. There may be special circumstances, such as temporary prolongation of life, which would make starting them appropriate. All life-supportive treatments should also be stopped at the patient's request. Beyond life-supportive treatments, other treatments requested by the patient should be subject to medical standards of practice.
Friday, May 20, 2005
$aving a $carce Re$ource: No Right to Artificial Nutrition and Hydration
In the Schiavo affair, there were no questions raised about providing artificial nutrition and hydration (ANH) if the patient herself wanted it to continue. The debate was whether to terminate ANH as her surrogate voiced her wishes. But when a national health service is paying the bill, there is a certain concern raised about providing ANH which was represented as the beginning of a slippery slope encouraging patients to request other “not appropriate” treatment. Leslie Burke, 45 was the patient involved. He has a degenerative brain condition and last July, in a British court, won the right to stop doctors withdrawing artificial nutrition or hydration treatment until he dies naturally. The original ruling was hailed as a breakthrough for the rights of terminally ill patients.
However the General Medical Council(GMC)which regulates medical practice in the U.K. and the Secretary of State for Health has appealed. The full article in the Scotsman.com on May 18, 2005 tells the whole story but here are excerpts.
"A right by patients to demand life-prolonging treatment has ‘very serious implications’for National Health Service (NHS) resources, appeal judges were told today. …
Backing a GMC bid to reverse the ruling, the health department claimed that if a right to ANH was established, patients would be able to demand other life-prolonging treatments.
Philip Sales, representing the Health Secretary, told a panel of three appeal judges… ‘A general right, as identified by the judge in the High Court), for an individual patient to require life-prolonging medical treatment has very serious implications for the functioning of the NHS. It may be interpreted as giving patients the right to demand certain treatments, contrary to the considered judgment of their medical team, that would lead to patients obtaining access to treatment that is not appropriate for them, and to inefficient (and unfairly skewed) use of resources within the NHS.’”
Do you think what is unsaid here may be the concern that the ANH would be keeping patients alive too long? The case is still pending in appeal. I will try to get a followup. ..Maurice.
However the General Medical Council(GMC)which regulates medical practice in the U.K. and the Secretary of State for Health has appealed. The full article in the Scotsman.com on May 18, 2005 tells the whole story but here are excerpts.
"A right by patients to demand life-prolonging treatment has ‘very serious implications’for National Health Service (NHS) resources, appeal judges were told today. …
Backing a GMC bid to reverse the ruling, the health department claimed that if a right to ANH was established, patients would be able to demand other life-prolonging treatments.
Philip Sales, representing the Health Secretary, told a panel of three appeal judges… ‘A general right, as identified by the judge in the High Court), for an individual patient to require life-prolonging medical treatment has very serious implications for the functioning of the NHS. It may be interpreted as giving patients the right to demand certain treatments, contrary to the considered judgment of their medical team, that would lead to patients obtaining access to treatment that is not appropriate for them, and to inefficient (and unfairly skewed) use of resources within the NHS.’”
Do you think what is unsaid here may be the concern that the ANH would be keeping patients alive too long? The case is still pending in appeal. I will try to get a followup. ..Maurice.
Thursday, May 19, 2005
More On Weeding Out Medical Ethical Misfits
"Finding oneself in the hands of an unethical physician can be a terrifying experience. How can we know whether the physician to whom we entrust our bodies and our confidences seriously lacks medical ethics? Are government and medical community safeguards effective in weeding out unsafe doctors?" So writes Philip R. Alper,Robert Wesson Fellow in Scientific Philosophy and Public Policy at the Hoover Institution in the Hoover Digest titled "Why Medical Ethics Matter". It is worth reading as we continue the discussion of the topic of weeding out medical misfits. Alper contrasts the various approaches through the centuries to establish professional behavior from the threatening Code of Hammurabi to the motivating Oath of Hippocrates and to the perhaps legally scripted American Medical Association's Code of Medical Ethics and finally to the complex recently developed Charter of Medical Professionalism. The latter, according to Alper "created by three preeminent internal medicine organizations in the United States and Europe, ... speaks in near-religious terms of 'three fundamental principles and ten commitments' (the latter actually total 36 by my count when compound sentences are teased apart) that would challenge a genius to comprehend and a saint to perform." Do you think these literal guideposts to ethical behavior accomplish what they were intended? Can you suggest other approaches to this issue? ..Maurice.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)