Monday, October 31, 2005

Want to Do Hospital Committee Ethics? (2): Ventilating the Dead

FACTS:
The ICU of the hospital is filled to capacity and there is a patient with a myocardial infarction who is awaiting a bed there. One of the patients already in the ICU for the past 2 days is J.W., a 34 year old white male, who lives at home with his widowed mother. There are no other family members. The patient suffered a ruptured aneurysm of the brain with massive bleeding into the brain and is totally unresponsive, cannot breathe without the ventilator and meets all the criteria for death by neurologic criteria (“brain death”). The patient’s physician and a consulting neurosurgeon has told the mother that even though the patient’s heart is still beating for a while if the ventilator continues to work, her son is dead and the physician is going to write an order to stop all treatments including the ventilator.

THE ISSUE: The mother rejects the conclusion that her son is dead and says that he is warm and pink and “breathing” and that he is still alive and may, if the treatment is not stopped, have a chance for a miracle recovery. She says that under no circumstances should the ventilator be stopped and if necessary she will take her son home with a ventilator. She says she can arrange for him to be cared for at home. The physicians call for the hospital ethics committee to meet and the plan of the committee is to have the physicians, attending nurses and the mother sitting together in a quiet room to discuss the issue with the committee.

THE QUESTIONS:

What should the ethics committee first hope to hear from the mother?
What should the ethics committee ask the mother?
What should the ethics committee ask the physicians?
What ethical issues should be considered?
What other information should the physicians or ethics committee relate to the mother?
What should the ethics committee consider as a reasonable and ethical outcome decision to be made by the physicians and the mother?

If you would be sitting as an impartial ethics committee member what thoughts would be going through your head? ..Maurice.

Saturday, October 29, 2005

Want to Do Hospital Committee Ethics? (1): Withdrawal of MNH

This scenario will be the first in a series of scenarios that are examples of what hospital ethics committees experience. One of the roles of ethics committee members is to come to a consensus and inform the stakeholders about the ethics and the current law regarding the issue and anticipated action.

For this exercise to be of interest and worthwhile, it will require my visitors reading the scenario to contribute their comments regarding the issue. Remember, you don’t have to be a professional ethicist to give an opinion; you just have to be an interested member of society.

FACTS:
94-year-old Catholic woman with advanced Alzheimer’s Disease,
5-year resident of a Catholic care facility.
A feeding tube to provide medical nutrition and hydration (MNH) was placed a few years ago because of difficulty swallowing during a prolonged respiratory infection, with the intention that it would be temporary but the feeding tube still remains in the patient. It is not clear why the tube was left in place but, perhaps, it was providing good nutrition without complications and was more efficient for the nurses.
The patient now has moderately severe trouble swallowing attributed to Alzheimer’s..
The patient has no terminal illness. She has only severe Alzheimer’s yet is still aware of her environment.
Years ago, while mentally competent the patient prepared an Advance Directive stating that she did not want medical nutrition and hydration(MNH).
The family wishes to have the feeding tube removed.
There has been no recent change in the patient’s condition.

THE ISSUES:
Should the feeding tube be removed now from the patient? Is the intention of removal of the tube a decision to end the patient’s life, if she can’t be adequately given oral food and fluid or is the decision to relieve the patient of an extraordinary burden imposed by the tube. Should the physician be compelled to have the tube removed even if the physician, for moral and religious reasons, does not want to write an order for this act?
What if the nurses refuse to follow an order to have the tube removed?
Would it make any difference in the analysis of the issue if the patient was NOT Catholic and was a resident in a NON-CATHOLIC care facility?

DECISIONS: Now it is up to you my dear visitors to tell us all your opinions. ..Maurice.

Friday, October 28, 2005

When Medications Fail to Work: Is It Pharmacological or Psychosocial?

Not infrequently, physicians find that their patients are not responding to the prescribed therapy. The elevated blood pressure doesn’t improve, the elevated blood sugars are not falling, the signs and symptoms of congestive heart failure are still present. The physician may scratch his or her head wondering why there was a lack of therapeutic efficacy. But it may not be that the prescribed medication wasn’t effective, it may be that the prescribed medication was not taken properly or even not taken. Pharmacists Kenreigh and Wagner posting in the Medscape web article about medication adherence report that a recent study “found that the risk of hospitalization was more than double in patients with diabetes mellitus, hypercholesterolemia, hypertension, or congestive heart failure who were nonadherent to prescribed therapies compared with the general population.” The article suggests that patients with chronic illnesses are more likely to fail adherence to a prescribed medical program than those with acute illnesses. In addition, issues of literacy of the patient should be considered as a factor.

There are a couple other factors involved in non-compliance not specifically mentioned in the article which should also be considered. One involves the doctor-patient relationship and the degree of confidence the patient has in the doctor. Doctors who don’t or can’t take the time to explain to the patient’s understanding the therapy and schedules could face non- or poor compliance response by the patient. Schedules are often an important factor in poor compliance especially if the schedules fail to take into account the patient’s individual scheduling problems. The other involves financial burdens placed on the patient and the decisions patients have to make with regard to how they allocate their available income to the various necessities.

One change in the system that is greatly needed is that the physician become more educated and kept updated on the cost of medications. Ask your doctor to tell you the cost of a drug. I bet he or she can't give you a spontaneous answer. It is a simple task to select a drug that has been shown to be potentially pharmacologically effective. But that is only one factor for the physician to consider. The other obviously includes the medical risks of the drug but yet another is the financial burden of the medication to the patient. That requires an knowledge of the cost of the medication and the financial status of the patient. Perhaps physicians should take time to also discussing this burden with the patient and, if necessary, prescribe a medication perhaps not as “new” or direct-to-consumer advertised which could be equally effective. But I just wonder how often physicians do that.

The reflex response by a doctor when a medication doesn’t seem to be working should not be to change drugs. It should be first to establish whether the patient is taking the medication or taking the medication as prescribed. And then, if this is the problem, the physician should try to mitigate it. ..Maurice.

Tuesday, October 25, 2005

Expectation in Medicine

In my previous postings on the angry patient, I think much of the etiology of the anger is related to the simple and common psychologic activity of expectation. We all generally go into a medical relationship, either as the patient or the physician, expecting something good to come out of it. But as Emily Dickinson seems to be warning us, expectation, though anticipated as satisfactory may lead to, one might say, unexpected consequences.

”Expectation—is Contentment” by Emily Dickinson

Expectation -- is Contentment --
Gain -- Satiety --
But Satiety -- Conviction
Of Necessity

Of an Austere trait in Pleasure --
Good, without alarm
Is a too established Fortune --
Danger -- deepens Sum --


What is being expected in medicine? From the patient’s viewpoint, it is having a pleasant and empathetic and conscientious physician who has the knowledge and skill to treat satisfactorily the illness. Additionally, the physician is expected to take or make the time to listen to the patient, perform a proper examination and communicate in way that the patient understands the diagnosis and the recommendations. The physician’s office must also reflect the same personal attention that is being provided by the physician. I think that these qualities are something which most patients expect.

What is being expected from a physician’s viewpoint? I think doctors want the patient and the family, in general, to be tolerant regarding the limits of medical practice in the 21st century. That they should be realistic and therefore be understanding and supportive of the issues the physician faces with regard to office management as well as diagnosis and treatment management. Specifically, the doctors want an educated patient or one who can be easily educated in personal medical matters and desires to be compliant. They want a patient who presents with a problem that can, even if challenging, be managed by the physician to the benefit of the patient.

Unfortunately, for both parties, expectations may never be fully realized to the anguish of each. To the patient, in many ways, if the physician fails to meet the patient’s needs, the resulting discomfort adds to the burden of the illness itself. To the physician, if the patient, the family, the disease or the response to treatment fail to be the hoped for ideal, personal or professional confidence may be lost and the physician may project the loss toward the patient or family. And so with expectations by one party or the other or both, not leading to that “contentment”, the relationship deteriorates and display of the discontent including anger in one form or the other may appear.

What do you think a patient or a physician expect out of their relationship? ..Maurice.

Saturday, October 22, 2005

The Angry Patient (2) and the Internet

What about angry patients expressing their feelings not solely to the doctor involved but broadcasting it to the world on an Internet Web site? This is happening, as documented in a Wall Street Journal article of September 14, 2005. This behavior by patients has led to various libel lawsuits. As noted in the article there are, of course, two views of the issue:


"The potential problems are huge," said Matt Messina, a dentist in Fairview Park, Ohio, and a spokesman for the American Dental Association. "My reputation is my stock in trade … and we work years and years to build that reputation. To have that shattered potentially [by an Internet posting] is a concern."

Patient advocates, meanwhile, say patients have First Amendment rights to describe their experiences with physicians. "Blogs and personal Web sites are no different than talking over the back fence," said Charles Inlander, president of People's Medical Society, a patient advocacy group in Allentown, Pa. "Those who read it have to take it with whatever grain of salt you would take, just like a neighbor. It's too bad if doctors are insulted by this."


If a disgruntled patient is asked by a neighbor for a recommendation for a doctor, specifically the patient’s doctor, is it slander to tell that neighbor about the patient’s own unhappy experience? If it is part of our right to free speech, then is this act just as permissible if same description of the doctor is displayed on a Web site? According to the Columbia University Press Encyclopedia, “In recent years, the U.S. Supreme Court has allowed that only factual misrepresentation is to be considered libel or slander, not expression of opinion. It has also ruled that libel suits may be filed across state lines, not only in the state where the plaintiff lives.”

The law is one aspect but what about the ethics? Is it ethical to “spread the word” of one’s personal anger. Well, the way I would look at it would be all about intent. If the intent was to present to others only the facts about one’s own personal experience with a physician and not to generalize about how that physician might behave with another patient or to demean or degrade the physician then this act might be ethical. However, if the intent is specifically to do damage to the physician and his or her practice, this would be maleficent, unjust and therefore unethical. What do you think of an angry patient expressing personal discontent on the Internet? ..Maurice.

Friday, October 21, 2005

The Angry Patient

The Angry Patient

The angry patient is a like a thorn suddenly
Pricking the finger of the unwary doctor
But, perhaps, sticking there with great pain and consternation
The doctor trying some way to pull it out
And not push it in deeper

I want to expound a bit on my poem. In our American and perhaps generally within the western culture, physicians will experience sometime in their practice angry patients. The anger may be expressed directly to the physician because of some sort of unhappiness which was experienced by the patient. The experience could have been happened during care by a previous physician but the patient is entering the new relationship with much suspicion and may want to set control. The patient may be dissatisfied by something currently experienced and may represent unhappiness with the physician or the office. Or sometimes the anger may represent an attempt by the patient to exert control in any way because of anxiety and fear about the patient’s own illness for which therapeutic control is lacking. Whatever the basis of the anger, the presence of an angry patient confronting the physician presents a challenge to that doctor. There is the natural reaction for the physician to be immediately defensive and return anger with a similar behavior except for one thing.. the basis of all medical care: the aim of medicine to be therapeutic. And returning anger is not productive and certainly not therapeutic. So what guidelines can a physician use to be therapeutic in the response?

On the website of The Reporter publication by the Texas Medical Liability Trust, I found a great article by Barbara Rose on how to defuse angry patients. I would like to present the article’s suggestions (References are listed in the article):_


• Be curious; ask why they are angry as this
may have a therapeutic effect.
• Don’t be defensive and engage in a power
struggle.
• Listen carefully; this alone may defuse the
patient’s anger.
• Use active-listening techniques — repetition,
summary, validation, and empathetic statements.2
When physicians are uncomfortable interacting
with a patient, a barrier to effective communication
exists. “Being aware of the tension, identifying the
barrier, and acknowledging with the patient that
there is difficulty in the relationship are important
steps in re-establishing understanding between a
patient and clinician.” 2
In Anger Management Techniques, J. Alfonso
describes visceral responses that may defuse a heated
encounter with a patient.
• Maintain slow and steady breathing.
• Monitor the pace and tone of your voice. Speak
slowly and calmly.
• Maintain open body language as a nonverbal
sign of listening. 3
Also, avoid standing with your hands on your
hips, in your pockets, or arms crossed as this body
language connotes a defensive reaction.
What if the source of the anger legitimately rests
within your practice? A patient who experienced
difficulty in scheduling an appointment, a long
waiting time, or unresponsive staff members will
very likely direct anger toward the physician. Use
the techniques listed above. Get specifics and give
the patient assurance that the matter will be acted
on and resolved. Don’t avoid the angry or dissatisfied
patient. Being an advocate for your patients will
enhance your effectiveness. “As difficult as it may
be, the more you talk with and listen to an angry
patient, the more likely you are to avoid converting
an incident into a claim.” 4
Another model for dealing effectively with critical
and angry patients triggered by events in your practice
suggests the following:
1. Make a disarming statement, e.g. “You are
right. You did have to wait today.” This is nondefensive
and validates some of what the patient
is saying.
2. Make an empathic statement, e.g. “Your time is
important and it is frustrating when you have to
wait.” This reflects putting yourself in the
patient’s position and understanding his or her
needs.
3. Make an inquiry, e.g. “What can we do to
resolve this problem today?” This demonstrates
your shared relationship and interest in the
patient and may move the exchange to a productive
solution. 5


These are all excellent suggestions. But, physicians are human too and an angry patient can strain sometimes the strongest self-confidence. However, I think if the physician looks at the patient’s expression of anger as a patient symptom and tries, with the help of these guidelines, to understand and then treat the symptom, the experience will be something positive and perhaps of value to all involved.

I would be most interested in reading from my visitors whether they, as patients, displayed anger at their physician and how the physician responded. Did the doctor demonstrate any of the guidelines as noted above? What was the outcome? Again, no names please. ..Maurice.

Tuesday, October 18, 2005

Teaching of Medical Students to Become Physicians (3): The Middle Finger, Index Finger Trick

As the old story goes:

First-year students at Medical School were receiving their first anatomy class with a real dead human body. They all gathered around the surgery table with the body covered with a white sheet. The professor started the class by telling them, "In medicine, it is necessary to have two important qualities as a doctor: the first is that you can not be disgusted by anything involving the human body". For an example, the professor pulled back the sheet, stuck his finger in the butt of the corpse, withdrew it and stuck it in his mouth. "Go ahead and do the same thing," he told his students. The students freaked out, hesitated for several minutes, but eventually took turns sticking a finger in the butt of the dead body and sucking on it. When everyone finished, the professor looked at them and told them, "The second most important quality is observation. I stuck in my middle finger and sucked on my index finger. Now learn to pay attention."

Would you believe that I actually watched a physician, teaching 2nd year medical students the skill of observation, performing virtually the same deception? However the physician used a plastic cup filled with a yellowish liquid he identified as urine and did the same middle finger, index finger trick and actually got a student up in front of his fellow students to stick in a finger then suck. Then the physician admitted that the container was not filled with urine but actually a potable drink. Everyone laughed.

Though it was all fun and hopefully educational, I always wondered whether this act was really ethical and fair, taking advantage of a vulnerable young medical student.
Am I being overly concerned about this particular way of teaching? Or should our teaching of medical students, including those in the later years on the wards, be tempered by more concern with ethical boundaries? ..Maurice.