Sunday, November 20, 2005

A History of Medical Professionalism and Ethics and Some Questions

As a segue from the previous posting about the medical professionalism issue of Dr. Vlasak’s speech and also as a followup on a number of previous postings on “physicians wearing two hats” and other professionalism issues and along with current concerns about the treatment or torture of military prisoners, I have posted below a very good brief summary of the history of medical professionalism and ethics which was recently written to a bioethics listserv. The author, from whom I have permission to reproduce his writing here, is Robert Baker, PhD, Chair, Alden March Bioethics Institute
Professor of Bioethics, Graduate College of Union University and
Professor of Philosophy, Union College. Read the history and then maybe you could comment on what points in medical professionalism you would emphasize in terms of physician public advocacy or simultaneously wearing another occupational hat if you were writing a code of ethics for doctors. ..Maurice.


The modern concept of a professional is absent from eighteenth century English (e.g. is not to be found in Dr. Samuel Johnson's Dictionary 1755 and later eds.) emerging in the early nineteenth century initially in Percival's Medical Ethics (1803). In that book Percival looks back to Cicero and Stoic philosophy (the source of an early effort to create a notion of professionalism by the Greek physician Scribonius Largus, fl. 14-54 CE ) to offer the concept of an occupational role, that of physicians and/or surgeons, whose obligations--because they entail duties of service to others--transcend that of mere employee, and whose prerogatives are justified by an implicit social contract which makes their position a "public trust" (Percival's words). Percival's innovative conception was ignored by physicians and surgeons everywhere--except for a few receptive young men in America. These men would ultimately draft a code of medical ethics for the AMA in 1847. By means of the code and the AMA the concept of being a professional (and the correlative notion of unprofessional conduct) gradually displaced the older conception of the physician as gentleman bound by precepts of gentlemanly honor. American conceptions of professionalism and professional ethics--with it presumptions of competence formally bound by medical ethics-- did not definitively displace older concept of honor until the end of WWII (a post-Holocaust/post-Nuremberg phenomenon).

To teach professionalism, in my view, is to teach both how and why the concept was constructed, as well as the nature and limitations of its construction--it is to teach the lived experience of medicine, the history of its response and failures to respond to a variety of challenges.

More specifically, it is not self-evident that physicians shouldn't act as patriots, and use their medical knowledge to aid their countryman and to thwart its enemies.


Hippocrates VITAE --a life of Hippocrates written some time after his death--states clearly that Hippocrates refused to treat Persians suffering from a plague because they were the enemies of the Greeks. Benjamin Rush (1745-1813) lectured to his students using this example to argue that physicians must be patriots.

(See: Jouanna, Jacques. Hipporcrate Translated as Hippocrates by M. B. DeBevoise (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1999; Temkin, Owsei. Hippocrates in a World of Pagans and Christians. (Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1991).


The notion that physicians are above the battle and should treat the wounded from all sides emerges from military medicine. It becomes wedded to professionalism only after the formation of the World Medical Association in 1947 and is a post-Holocaust phenomenon. Hence the importance of teaching not only the Nuremberg trials--but the international codes of medical ethics, oaths and declarations that derive from them.

As physicians became involved in military conflicts in the second half of the twentieth century-- British physicians' treatment of IRA hunger strikers, the revelations of physician complicity at the South African Truth and Reconciliation Hearings (http://shr.aaas.org/trc-med/default.htm ), etc.,--medical societies began to rethink the obligations of physicians.

What sort of medical care/information should they supply in these contexts? Should they force feed prisoners? Do they have a professional obligation to protest torture? To reveal what they see? etc.

Friday, November 18, 2005

Free Speech vs Ethics of Medical Professionalism: Is There a Boundary?

Did anyone watch CBS's "60 Minutes" on Sunday? The one segment I wish to consider is the one on "eco-terrorists" and particularly the Animal Liberation Front and Dr. Jerry Vlasak, a practicing trauma surgeon in Southern California, who is an apparent spokesperson for some extreme animal rights groups and who has told audiences that it is time to consider assassinating people who do research on animals.

The Animal Liberation Front (ALF) website quotes Dr. Vlasak as saying:

“I think there is a use for violence in our movement. And I think it can be an effective strategy. Not only is it morally acceptable, I think that there are places where it could be used quite effectively from a pragmatic standpoint.

For instance, if vivisectors were routinely being killed, I think it would give other vivisectors pause in what they were doing in their work - and if these vivisectors were being targeted for assassination, and call it political assassination or what have you, I think if -- and I wouldn't pick some guy way down the totem pole, but if there were prominent vivisectors being assassinated, I think that there would be a trickle-down effect and many, many people who are lower on that totem pole would say, ‘I'm not going to get into this business because it's a very dangerous business and there's other things I can do with my life that don't involve getting into a dangerous business.’ And I think that the -- strictly from a fear and intimidation factor, that would be an effective tactic.[ Ref: Dr. Jerry Vlasak Replies to Media Libel]

And I don't think you'd have to kill -- assassinate -- too many vivisectors before you would see a marked decrease in the amount of vivisection going on. And I think for 5 lives, 10 lives, 15 human lives, we could save a million, 2 million, 10 million non-human animals.

And I -- you know - people get all excited about, "Oh what's going to happen when - the ALF accidentally kills somebody in an arson?" Well, you know I mean -- I think we need to get used to this idea. It's going to happen, okay? It's going to happen.”


In the ALF link above, the Animal Liberation Front defends Dr. Vlasak’s comments with:

In making these claims, Vlasak certainly entered into controversial territory, shocked and angered vivisectors and other speciesists, and even got banned from the UK. But his words fall squarely within the First Amendment of the US Constitution and therefore are constitutionally protected. The very essence of the First Amendment is to protect unpopular speech, words that many people might find offensive and objectionable, statements such as Vlasak made at the AR2003 conference. Everyone knows that exploiters of any kind love free speech so long as they are the ones using it in honor of their detestable motives and unconscionable actions. Had Vlasak actually advocated violence against vivisectors in such a way as to incite and possibly provoke immanent violence, he would have crossed a legal line. Despite the frenzied distortions of critics who favor violence toward animals but not toward humans, Vlasak in fact did not cross this line.


My concern is not about Dr. Vlasak’s view on the treatment of animals. He has every right to his view and to his wide-spread dissemination of his view even as a physician. Incidentally, with regard to that view, it is difficult for me to understand the rationale a physician against animal research can give treating emergency room patients with instruments and drugs and procedures that are the result of animal experimentation. On the other hand I wonder how a humanistic physician can have compassion for a patient and working for patient survival and at the same time bear views and at times broadcasting the suggestion to kill those humans with whom he disagrees but who have not committed any crime or penalized with a death sentence by the courts?

The issue I would like to present is whether speech that may be considered as free speech and within legal bounds for a layperson becomes restricted speech for a physician. In other words, does becoming a physician and accepting the professional role as set by society, sets a boundary to free speech which is limited by the ethics set by the profession of medicine. All physicians, I believe, should be humanistic in their intent and their acts. Thus speech by a physician should not be free that encourages vigilantes to kill persons carrying out some unacceptable but legal activities. ..Maurice.

Thursday, November 17, 2005

More on Politics and Religion Trumping Science

It seems to me very likely that the FDAs rejection of over-the-counter availability for Plan B was an example of politics and religion acting to trump science and setting restrictions on what should be autonomous personal behavior. I would like to present another gross example of such trumping, through the HIV/AIDS prevention and treatment funds for Africa provided by the U.S. government. This behavior of the U.S. government may have an even more disastrous effect than the restrictions of Plan B procurement.

The Human Rights Watch, in their most recent study, presents us with the situation in Uganda where previous improvement in the HIV/AIDS epidemic is now worsening and suggests the cause may be the restriction of funding unless the teaching is that abstinence until marriage is the primary approach and general condom use is to be de-emphasized. The statistical facts regarding the weakness of abstinence teaching in preventing HIV/AIDS and the scientifically known strength of condoms is ignored by the U.S. funding source. Please read the following Conclusion and go to the above link to read the entire report. ..Maurice.

As an activist and woman living with AIDS, it makes me feel judged. You are supposed to abstain and be faithful. Condoms are only for those who are promiscuous. I got HIV in marriage. I was faithful in my relationship. The battle to come out and be open was a struggle. Now, instead of moving forward, we are moving strides back.
—Ugandan woman living with AIDS

Uganda is unique among African nations for its early and high-level leadership against HIV/AIDS. The government’s willingness to address HIV/AIDS openly and break taboos surrounding sexually transmitted diseases is widely acknowledged as the cornerstone of its early success against the epidemic. By involving a wide range of nongovernmental organizations in the AIDS struggle and allowing candid messages about sex to reach a wide audience, Uganda achieved high levels of awareness of HIV, increased voluntary HIV testing, and ultimately fewer new HIV infections.
Today, this progress may unravel as U.S.-funded organizations scale up programs that promote sexual abstinence and fidelity within heterosexual marriage to the exclusion of all other HIV prevention strategies. These programs deprive young people of information that could save their lives. They mock the plight of countless Ugandan women and girls who abstain until marriage and are faithful within it but nevertheless become infected with HIV. They provide scant information or assistance to those at highest risk of HIV infection, including street children who trade sex for survival, children affected by conflict, and lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender youth. They distort factual information about condoms and safer sex strategies, placing young people at a higher risk of HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases.

As their proponents admit, abstinence-only programs are not simply about preventing HIV/AIDS, but about promoting moral values. However, censoring or distorting factual information about HIV/AIDS is not a moral value. Moreover, casting HIV/AIDS as a “moral” disease that results from “promiscuity”—as abstinence-only programs invariably do—reinforces the deadly stigma associated with HIV/AIDS. Throughout the 1990s, Uganda stood for the idea that AIDS could affect anyone, not simply “promiscuous” people. This idea proved critical to respecting the human rights of people living with AIDS and protecting them from violence and discrimination. Now, abstinence-only programs give Ugandans a new reason to stigmatize people living with AIDS and to judge their actions as immoral or blameworthy.

To its credit, Uganda continues to recognize that its young people face a high risk of HIV infection and has faced up to that challenge by expanding school-based sex education programs. However, as a perceived global leader in HIV prevention, Uganda is accountable to evidence and best practices in HIV prevention. The country’s high-profile U-turn toward unproven HIV prevention strategies for young people has, at this writing, already begun to resonate throughout other parts of Africa. Its complicity in the rewriting of history around its HIV prevention “success” could have implications on HIV prevention programs for years to come. Ultimately, it is not just Ugandans who will pay the price for the country’s back-steps in HIV prevention. It is the entire effort against the global AIDS pandemic.

Monday, November 14, 2005

Plan B and FDA: Why Can't Science Trump Politics?

From today’s San Jose Mercury News, the following headline and the following article excerpt


Report stokes charges of political meddling over `morning after' pill

BY TONY PUGH

WASHINGTON - Top officials at the Food and Drug Administration appear to have decided to block over-the-counter sales of a controversial emergency contraceptive months before completing their review of the application in 2004, a new government report said Monday.
According to the Government Accountability Office, top officials - some of them political appointees of President Bush - took "unusual" steps to impede the approval process.
The GAO's findings renew accusations of political meddling at the FDA, which has been criticized for more than two years for failing to bring the Plan B contraceptive to market despite the urging of its scientific staff. ...
Dr. Janet Woodcock, the FDA's deputy commissioner for operations, denied the allegations as well in a written response filed with the GAO. ...
In a written response to the report, the FDA's Woodcock took issue with its contention that high-level FDA management was more involved in the Plan B review than usual. She said the level of public interest necessitated the involvement of top officials at the FDA's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research.


I think it is pitiful that a governmental agency whose duty is to protect the public is apparently, in my view, simply protecting the votes for some politicians; another example of FDA organizational unethics. ..Maurice.

Saturday, November 12, 2005

More on Organ Transplant Injustice and Uncertainties

Our United States government continues to call for more organs to be procured and the transplant programs continue, but is the whole program as thought out and transparent as it could be? The U.S. organ transplant program with its social as well as clinical consequences is not as uncomplicated and rosy as those who are not involved might think. There is much uncertainty for recipient patients and their families if the patient is put on a organ waiting list such as how long is the wait going to be, will an organ be available before the patient dies and if one is transplanted what complications will occur, what will be the quality of life and how long will life be extended. There are protocols for the just distribution of organs but as seen in the case of St.Vincent Medical Center, unknown to the patients and their families, they don’t always work.

To demonstrate some of the uncertainties patients experience, two visitors recently wrote me the following comments and questions about the transplantation process.

“I received a liver transplant last year. The group that I was with in the post transplant clinic had a mean age of 50. Most of them have HCV, and most will be asking for a retransplant within 5 years. If retransplanted, %35 will not leave the hospital. The long term survival rate for the rest is all over the grid.

Should retransplant even be reconsidered? If so, who gets one? “




From another visitor:




“I recieved a liver tramsplant a year ago June. Like the majority of liver transplant patients( LTP) I have HCV. The HCV returned within a year. I went from stage 1 to stage 3.5 in 6 months.

There is no protocol for re-transplantation of HCV patients. Many are never the less performed on a "case by case" basis.

Having a retransplant performed in India is an option. $ 75 grand and a partial donor in-tow seems to be all they require. Their sucess rate seems to be inline with many domestic institutes. The primary motivation of the Indians is money. Oh yea, the Solons of our domestic medical institutes claim to be above such pedestrian motives as money; try to get a transplant without it.

So, does one take $ 75 grand, plus, and lawyer-up, and then take it your former life savers. Or does one blast off to New Delhi in hopes of a sucessful outcome?”



Finally, from the November 10, 2005 issue of the Los Angeles Times,I have excerpted the following disclosure which would be unpleasant news for patients and families involved regarding what has been going on at the University of California at Irvine. Please go to the link above and read the entire article.

Irvine Liver Transplant Program Loses Government Approval
By Charles Ornstein and Alan Zarembo, Times Staff Writers

The federal government today rescinded its approval for the liver transplant program at UC Irvine Medical Center after The Times reported that more than 30 people died awaiting liver transplants in the last two years as the hospital turned down scores of donated organs. …

The move means that many of the 106 patients on UC Irvine's waiting list for a liver transplant will have to be transferred to lists at other hospitals. Twenty eight of those people were added to the roster this year -- despite a staffing shortage that dampens their prospects for a transplant.
Although patients may not know it, the UC Irvine Medical Center has not had a full-time liver transplant surgeon since July 2004…

The low number of surgeries was not because of a lack of offers. Between August 2004 and July 2005, the hospital received 122 liver offers, most of them from the regional organ procurement agency, which coordinates donations and offers in Southern California. But only 12 were transplanted, including two that went to the same patient because the first one failed, according to an Aug. 5 federal report obtained by The Times under the Freedom of Information Act.

Even when patients did get transplants, the report says, they did not fare as well as they should have. Only 68.6% of patients who received liver transplants at UCI from January 2002 to June 2004 survived at least a year -- well below the 77% survival rate required for federal certification.


What does this all mean? You tell me! ..Maurice.

Thursday, November 10, 2005

AMA on Torture (2): Potential Conflict Between Ethics and Law

I really didn’t know the answer to my concern regarding the opinion presented by the AMA I posed in my last post on Torture, so I wrote to a bioethics listserv to which I subscribe: “Is this opinion of the AMA applicable to physicians in the U.S. armed forces or to any physicians who might be working in the Central Intelligence Agency?” Herbert Rakatansky, M.D., a former member of the American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs (CEJA) wrote back to the list the following, which is reproduced here with Dr. Rakatansky’s permission.


CEJA Opinions are standards of professional behavior. They carry a moral imperative but have no legal power. A government such as a state may adopt them as standards and apply them as it sees fit. Most states use the AMA Code as a reference standard for what constitutes professional behavior, There is a printed version of the Code which is annotated with legal decisions from state and federal courts in which the Code is cited as part of the court decision. In the latest version (2004-5) the Opinion on torture has no citations. Just for example, the Opinion on capital punishment has 41 citations. So the CEJA Opinions carry the same moral weight for all physicians regardless of who they work for. It would be very dangerous for an employer, private or governmental to assert that ethical standards do not apply to it’s employees. If the employer is a government then some physician behaviors may be legal but not ethical . (Shades of Soviet Russia, Nazi Germany, etc.) We have a situation right now in [Rhode Island] where a convicted schizophrenic violent sex offender has reached the end of his sentence. The state has ordered a physician employed by the state to keep him locked up in the hospital. The physician feels that person does not need hospital level care – though he may need to be separated from society. That doctor has resigned from his state job citing the Code as part of his reason. I wrote an op-ed published in the Providence Journal which follows. The Code applies to all – enforcement is variable but doctors have the right and perhaps the obligation to consider the Opinions as a basis for their professional behavior. Herbert Rakatansky, M.D., FACP, FACG Clinical Professor of Medicine, Brown University


Herbert Rakatansky: Patients as prisoners

01:00 AM EST on Friday, November 4, 2005

THE CASE of the Rhode Island sex offender Todd McElroy, who has reached the terminus of his sentence but will remain locked up in a state psychiatric ward, has created a controversy. There are some who think he is a risk to society if released, and others who suggest that he has paid his price and should be released into some "observational" and supervised status.
He apparently has a diagnosis of schizophrenia and perhaps other disorders. Many schizophrenics do quite well on medications. Hospitalizations tend to be short, and devoted to resolving acute situations and resuming or adjusting medications. In our Rhode Island case, then, a transfer to a psychiatric hospital might be medically indicated but of short duration.

Mr. McElroy will be in a state psychiatric ward at least until December, when a judge will determine whether he should be civilly committed for a longer time. The problem of preventing future destructive behavior would not be solved.
The proposition that doctors, at the behest of the state, commit him to hospitalization to isolate him is not acceptable; doctors cannot and should not address this problem. Only the judicial system, with appropriate due process, should have the right to deprive a person of liberty.

If the government believes that it is important to protect society from future criminal behavior, then the legislature and the judiciary must find a way to do this.
The court cannot make a medical diagnosis or prescribe a treatment; nor should it be able to order a doctor to make a specific diagnosis or prescribe a specific treatment, such as long-term hospitalization. (If the court sentences a person and that prisoner develops a physical or mental illness, the appropriate diagnosis and treatment, including hospitalization, are provided, based solely on the medical facts.)

The American Medical Association Code of Ethics addresses the issue of court-ordered treatment. It requires that the diagnosis be made by a doctor who is, in the case of a prisoner, likely to be employed by the state; another doctor, not employed by the state, must confirm the diagnosis.
The medical profession must generally accept the proposed treatment. Having the treatment approved by or included in guidelines approved by a national medical society specifically satisfies this criterion. This prevents a doctor or small group of doctors from administering "far-out," ineffective, or dangerous therapy ordered by the court.

Finally, informed consent must be obtained, to the extent possible, and confirmed by a doctor not employed by the state.
The present situation -- in which the state is asking that a doctor commit a person to an indefinite hospitalization for nonmedical reasons -- is analogous to the approval by the government of doctor participation in torture or execution. These actions may be "legal," but they are not ethical. In these situations, ethics trumps the law. If we accept this concept, there is no qualitative difference between physician participation in state-approved executions and what the doctors did in Nazi Germany. After all, the Nazi state said those experiments were legal. In the totalitarian Soviet Union, many political dissidents were committed to mental hospitals; this was legal, but I doubt that any of us would say that it was ethical.

Another danger is that the government may define such actions as being outside the practice of medicine, thus not allowing the Board of Licensure to deem them unprofessional. It has been said that these situations would never occur at this time in our society. But Illinois has decreed that physician participation in executions is not the practice of medicine. Also think about the recent revelations about doctor participation in torture of Iraqi prisoners.

Our government, at least initially, condoned and perhaps even encouraged these behaviors. Allowing the government to exclude any professional behavior from the definition of medical practice is a bright line that we should never cross!
So what should we do with our prisoner-patient? The legal system must decide whether the evidence substantiates that he is a risk to society, and, if so, deal with this problem. The role of the doctor is to provide the courts with medical data, the diagnosis, the role of treatment, and the expectation of success; the role of the courts is to afford due process and make the decision about deprivation of liberty.

I would not want to go to a doctor who accepted an order by the government to make a certain diagnosis and prescribe treatment that might not be medically indicated. And I doubt that you would want to go to that doctor, either.

Herbert Rakatansky, M.D., is a Brown University professor of medicine.

Wednesday, November 9, 2005

AMA on Torture

Here is the current American Medical Association ethics statement on torture.

E-2.067 Torture

Torture refers to the deliberate, systematic, or wanton administration of cruel, inhumane, and degrading treatments or punishments during imprisonment or detainment.
Physicians must oppose and must not participate in torture for any reason. Participation in torture includes, but is not limited to, providing or withholding any services, substances, or knowledge to facilitate the practice of torture. Physicians must not be present when torture is used or threatened.
Physicians may treat prisoners or detainees if doing so is in their best interest, but physicians should not treat individuals to verify their health so that torture can begin or continue. Physicians who treat torture victims should not be persecuted. Physicians should help provide support for victims of torture and, whenever possible, strive to change situations in which torture is practiced or the potential for torture is great. (I, III)
Issued December 1999.


This statement applies to all physicians including, I would hope, applying to physicians who are within the U.S. Armed forces and the C.I.A. ..Maurice.