Sunday, February 6, 2005

Blog Chatter: Lost Frozen Embryo

Gosh! I am impressed how the lost frozen embryo case in Illinois has stirred up such a host of opinions on the blogs. So many different takes. You can read them all if you have time on

Technorati.com.




Here is an analogy that I find very very interesting. It is written in Emily's Journal:
"A frozen embryo destroyed in a Chicago fertility clinic was a human being whose parents are entitled to file a wrongful-death lawsuit, a Cook County judge ruled Friday.'.........I stole this quote from a friend's journal, who got it from the Chicago Sun Times.

WOW.

The parallels between abortion issue and the slave issue of so long ago are just too close. Lets see. First, the argument is/was, 'Are they people?'....some have admitted 'Yes, but does that matter?'. Indeed, two arguments very strong in the slavery times. Now, here is where the parallels are even more close. In Congress so long ago, the Southern states said, 'our slaves should count in the population counts.' The Northern states said, 'But you do not treat them like people when you don't want to'. So, we see a little hypocracy....only people when it is convenient for them to be so. FINALLY, the three fifths compromise was reached. 'A slave would be counted as three fifths a person'.....often treated like less than human.

SO IT IS ONLY A HUMAN IN A CASE WHERE IT IS WANTED? "




Well.. what can anyone say to that? If a blastocyst is WANTED by society to be a living person than it IS a living person. If there is no science to support that it is a living person or not then it is NOT a living person. Gosh! How simple. Thanks Emily for the concept. ..Maurice.

More about Lost Frozen Embryos

Linda MacDonald Glenn, LLM writing in the November 2004 issue of

Virtual Mentor created a scenario, based on a real case, that is strikingly similar to the case from Illinois presented in my last posting. Go to the link above to read the entire article. However, she writes:


This scenario is based in part on a case brought in Rhode Island in 1995. A Superior Court issued a decision this past summer [2004] that frozen embryos were not "persons" within the meaning of the wrongful death statute and therefore could not be considered "victims" or "potential children." The court did not permit the plaintiffs to seek compensation for negligent infliction of emotional distress because the plaintiffs (1) did not witness the actual loss or destruction of the embryos, and (2) they did not suffer any physical manifestation of the emotional distress.



The Court, however, did hold that the frozen embryos were a form of "irreplaceable" property and allowed the plaintiffs to proceed with a claim for loss of "unique property." Despite the "informed consent" document [which included the disclaimer that "a laboratory accident in the Clinic may result in the loss or damage to one or more of said frozen embryos." ], the Court found that there remained a question of fact as to whether or not the plaintiffs were truly informed, that is, whether they fully understood "the possible risk associated with the loss or destruction of their pre-embryos." This aspect of the case has been remanded to the trial court and parties for further discovery and is still pending.




I suspect the Illinois law (see my last post) which apparently is similar to that in some other states will be eventually found to be in error by higher courts. ..Maurice.



Saturday, February 5, 2005

Frozen Embryo Destroyed: Wrongful Death or Breach of Contract?

The state of Illinois defines human life as beginning

at conception.
"Without in any way restricting the right of privacy of a

woman

or the right of a woman to an abortion under those decisions, the General

Assembly

of the State of Illinois do solemnly declare and find in reaffirmation of the

longstanding policy of this State, that the unborn child is a human being

from

the time of conception and is, therefore, a legal person for purposes of the

unborn child's right to life and is entitled to the right to life from

conception under

the laws and Constitution of this State. (720 ILCS 510/1) (from Ch. 38,

par. 81 21)"
In view of the law, this news item excerpted from the Chicago Sun Times is disconcerting and has significant implications.



February 5, 2005



BY STEVE PATTERSON AND ABDON M. PALLASCH Staff Reporters



A frozen embryo destroyed in a Chicago fertility clinic was a human being whose parents are entitled to file a wrongful-death lawsuit, a Cook County judge ruled Friday.



Attorneys on both sides of the abortion issue said it was the first such ruling they had heard of as the country debates whether stem cells derived from embryos can be used in research and medicine.



Alison Miller and Todd Parrish hoped to conceive a child with help from the Center for Human Reproduction, but the one fertilized egg the couple created was thrown out 'in error' by a clinic worker.



Friday, Judge Jeffrey Lawrence II said 'a pre-embryo is a 'human being' ... whether or not it is implanted in its mother's womb' and the couple is entitled to seek the same compensation awarded to other parents whose children are killed.



'Philosophers and theologians may debate,' he wrote, 'but there is no doubt in the mind of the Illinois Legislature when life begins. It begins at conception.'"



What do you think about this legal decision? Wouldn't it be considered more reasonable to consider the act of the clinic as a breach of contract or malpractice? ..Maurice.

Friday, February 4, 2005

Jokes, Issues and Actions

I just can't get away from jokes! In the previous postings, we have considered what might be the effects of jokes, enjoyable or upsetting. However,whatever else jokes do, jokes also often put into a concise yet amusing format important issues which are worthy of serious discussion and perhaps action.



Here is a medical joke or is it a auto-mechanic joke or is it requesting that we consider an ethical principle such as justice. Read the joke and then you frame it as you think about it. I got it from Aarons Jokes and it is simply called "Dr vs. Mechanic".





Morris was removing some engine valves from a car on the lift when he spotted the famous heart surgeon Dr.Michael DeBakey, who was standing off to the side, waiting for the service manager.



Morris, somewhat of a loud mouth, shouted across the garage, "Hey DeBakey...Is dat you? Come over here a minute."

The famous surgeon, a bit surprised, walked over to where Morris was working on a car. Morris in a loud voice, all could hear, said argumentatively, "So Mr. fancy doctor, look at this work. I also take valves out, grind 'em, put in new parts, and when I finish this baby will purr like a kitten.



So how come you get the big bucks, when you and me are doing basically the same work?"



DeBakey, very embarrassed, walked away, and said softly, to Morris, "Try doing your work with the engine running."



..Maurice.

Thursday, February 3, 2005

Jokes About Ethics and Exposing Its Cracks

OK. This joke from the UK website awordinyoureye

is not about illness but about ethics. I can accept this without feeling upset.



Issy was the proud co-owner of the local dry cleaners. One day, during dinner, whilst he was finishing his chicken soup, his 9year old son Sam asked, "Dad, what’s ethics?"

Issy thought for a while, put down his spoon, looked at Sam and replied, "Okay, let's suppose someone comes into my shop and gives me his business suit to dry clean. Then suppose I find a £20 note in his trouser pocket?"

Sam looked expectantly at his father.

"So," Issy said, "to answer your question, Sam, do I tell my partner I found the money? That's ethics".




Do my visitors have any more jokes about ethics? Ethics deserves it! Remember, ethics should not necessarily be looked at as a perfect monolithic doctrine as some might think it is. Jokes about ethics might expose some of the cracks which would be therapeutic for this discipline. Right? ..Maurice.

Wednesday, February 2, 2005

Making Fun of Illness? Think Again

Yesterday, I ended my posting with "Do you think it’s ethical to make fun of an illness and thus the anonymous ill patient? Do you see any benefit for the ill patient to hear the joke? Do you think that joking about illness is the human way of dealing with something perhaps over which we have no control.. and it's OK?" Dr. James Baker of Mental Notes thoughtfully found an answer to my questions after reading my posting. He wrote:
"When I read this, and ponder its ending query,

what comes to mind is this;

and this...

and this...

and this and this and this..

And I think to myself,

is not the answer to the query so darn obvious?"


Go to Dr. Baker's blog for the links to the blogs of this and this and this and this and this and this. I think you will see his obvious answer. ..Maurice.

Tuesday, February 1, 2005

The Ethics of Making Fun of an Illness

The DSM-IV classification of mental illness is, I suppose, an important tool that the psychiatrist uses as a help to make a diagnosis. I suspect that the pages of the document are well turned in every psychiatrist’s office. Well.. as a change of pace in contrast to the rather serious mood of my recent postings, I decided to offer another way of defining the various mental illnesses. I found the following humorous interpretation of psychiatric behaviors at Aha! Jokes





Psychiatrist phone

Hello. Welcome to the Psychiatric Hotline

If you are obsessive-compulsive, please press 1 repeatedly.

If you are co-dependent, please ask someone to press 2.

If you have multiple personalities, please press 3, 4, 5, and 6.

If you are paranoid-delusional, we know who you are and what you want. Just stay on the line so we can trace the call.

If you are schizophrenic, listen carefully and a little voice will tell you which number to press.

If you are manic-depressive, it doesn't matter which number you press. No one will answer.

If you are anxious, just start pressing numbers at random.

If you are phobic, don't press anything.

If you are anal retentive, please hold.




You may wonder what this all has to do with bioethics. There are many jokes around about illness. Do you think it’s ethical to make fun of an illness and thus the anonymous ill patient? Do you see any benefit for the ill patient to hear the joke?

Do you think that joking about illness is the human way of dealing with something perhaps over which we have no control.. and it's OK?



Oops! I’m getting serious again! ..Maurice.